Am I being unreasonable in the request I made to my MA?
#1
Am I being unreasonable in the request I made to my MA?
So I've been waiting a long time for my MINI to get to me. I decided recently that I would like to get the bonnet stripes on my car. I thought I would bring this up to my MA. The e-mail chain is below, am I being unreasonable? How should I reply?
First...you can have the stripes:-) Second....the only reason your car took soooooo long is because you changed your order more than once. Every time you did that it started the clock all over. Don't forget around the time you made some changes MINI had the problem with supply on Auto transmissions because of the Japan tragedy. If you want stripes than great.....just make sure it's what you want. Remember....that was the theme through this proses. I hope you are blown away when your car arrives.
Thanks,
-****
Two points about his last e-mail:
1) I did make changes two weeks after the initial order, but by my math I should still have received the car already.
2) Until that e-mail no one has contacted me to explain that their was a supply problem on auto transmissions.
Maybe I shouldn't say anything since they are giving me what I want, but I feel this need to reply, what should I do?
Subject: Bonnet Stripes
Hi ****,
So when I ordered my car I had decided I didn't want the bonnet stripes. In the time since I've changed my mind. Is it still possible to get the black bonnet stripes added to my car?
Thanks,
-Eddie
Hi ****,
So when I ordered my car I had decided I didn't want the bonnet stripes. In the time since I've changed my mind. Is it still possible to get the black bonnet stripes added to my car?
Thanks,
-Eddie
That is correct.
-****
-****
Great! Can you make that happen before I pick up the car? When I ordered I added the sport package which included the stripes, so will you be able to do this as part of the package so that I don't incur any additional charges?
-Eddie
-Eddie
Sorry Eddie, we gave you all the time you needed to make your car perfect, if you know what I mean:-).....if you want the stripes you will have to pay for them. The good news is we can sell them at a discounted rate. We also have a guy that does custom stripes.....IMAGINE THE POSSIBILITY'S!
-****
-****
Well it's definitely been a long time since I ordered, 10 weeks and 3 days to be exact. When I ordered I was told it would be only 6-8 weeks, and yet I still have no car. I was hoping that compounded with the fact that I ordered a car with ~15,000 in add-ons would allow you to do this one small favor.
I'll come into the dealership after work today so we can talk about it
-Eddie
I'll come into the dealership after work today so we can talk about it
-Eddie
First...you can have the stripes:-) Second....the only reason your car took soooooo long is because you changed your order more than once. Every time you did that it started the clock all over. Don't forget around the time you made some changes MINI had the problem with supply on Auto transmissions because of the Japan tragedy. If you want stripes than great.....just make sure it's what you want. Remember....that was the theme through this proses. I hope you are blown away when your car arrives.
Thanks,
-****
1) I did make changes two weeks after the initial order, but by my math I should still have received the car already.
2) Until that e-mail no one has contacted me to explain that their was a supply problem on auto transmissions.
Maybe I shouldn't say anything since they are giving me what I want, but I feel this need to reply, what should I do?
#2
At this point you should pay for them.
You ordered stripes delete, so now that the car is built the stripes now become a dealer add-on, just as if you were buying one off the lot. The dealer has to charge you for the stripe kit they stock since they had to buy it from MINI to start with. Also you can't expect them to eat the labor because you changed your mind. You seem to be very particular about how you want your MINI to look like so I would suggest taking delivery w/o stripes and take it to a vinyl shop and get what ever stripes you want and not be limited to what MINI offers. I bought my MINI used and the first thing I did was remove the stock stripes and installed aftermarket to make it MY MINI, a little different than the others out there. Good Luck
#3
Be thankful that you are getting what you asked for. Leave it at that. I think your MA was spot on--you made changes, so that wasn't MINI's fault. Yes, your math tells you that you should have had your car by now, but assembly, supply, and delivery are never hard-and-fast. Yes, it's been 10 weeks, but, again, that likely had nothing to do with MINI (but, rather, as stated, the supply problem).
He said you should pay for them since you originally didn't want them. Now you want them. Starting at zero and asking to add one usually means you pay for the one. I'm surprised that your MA is giving them to you, but good on ya. Be happy with it. Your MA did something that he/she didn't need to do--show some gratitude, be happy, and enjoy your car when it gets delivered.
He said you should pay for them since you originally didn't want them. Now you want them. Starting at zero and asking to add one usually means you pay for the one. I'm surprised that your MA is giving them to you, but good on ya. Be happy with it. Your MA did something that he/she didn't need to do--show some gratitude, be happy, and enjoy your car when it gets delivered.
#4
I'm very happy he's giving me the stripes, I just didn't like the way he worded his e-mails.
My friends keep telling me I should raise hell and ask for a lot more because of the wait I've had to endure. I'm not the type to complain normally, but I thought I would give it a shot with the stripes.
My friends keep telling me I should raise hell and ask for a lot more because of the wait I've had to endure. I'm not the type to complain normally, but I thought I would give it a shot with the stripes.
Last edited by TrueEddie; 06-27-2011 at 10:18 AM. Reason: spelling
#5
I don't know, the tone of the replies isn't quite what I would expect - although I don't know what all water has gone under the bridge.
I does strike me that after you made an issue of the extensive upgrades you added he became willing to add the stripes, but not previously. It always pisses me off when someone is only willing to do something after having pressure applied - it shows that there is not a real sense of a customer service ethic. I know car sales doesn't generally draw vetted professionals with extended education and ethics training, but it really sucks when you come across so many scum bags at the dealers (don't go to any Houston dealers!).
I does strike me that after you made an issue of the extensive upgrades you added he became willing to add the stripes, but not previously. It always pisses me off when someone is only willing to do something after having pressure applied - it shows that there is not a real sense of a customer service ethic. I know car sales doesn't generally draw vetted professionals with extended education and ethics training, but it really sucks when you come across so many scum bags at the dealers (don't go to any Houston dealers!).
#6
Sounds like the reason for the delays (auto trans) were not communicated very well to you... not sure if that is MA or perhaps MINI corporate issue.
Otherwise, like others have said, you wanted stripes deleted so they were not added at the factory. Now the dealership has to eat the parts + install cost.
It's great that they decided to add it at no cost to you with a little pressure.
Otherwise, like others have said, you wanted stripes deleted so they were not added at the factory. Now the dealership has to eat the parts + install cost.
It's great that they decided to add it at no cost to you with a little pressure.
#7
Fingers crossed that the boat carrying your car does not sink (it has happened - yikes!!).
Trending Topics
#8
#9
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2576179.stm
Included BMW's apparently.
#10
you are not out of line. you are purchasing an expensive automobile, and shouldn't be treated like you are buying a civic from carmax. no, it's not the MOST expensive car out there, but that shouldn't matter. good dealerships get their reputation from good customer service, not good cars. manufacturers get their rep from good cars.
if there was a delay in your order because of the tragedy in Japan, your MA should have called you or emailed you. i'm not saying you deserve a ton of stuff for free because of the way you were treated, but you definitely don't deserve to be treated like that. you have the power and right to not do business with them anymore. if you don't like how you've been treated, exercise that and warn others.
i've bought new and used cars, cheap and expensive, and i've been treated like royalty. when i bought my mini, i felt like just another number. yes, they were attentive and willing to serve when i bought the car and wrote the check, but after they had it, they completely forgot about me. i had to go back multiple times just to get the floor mats.
i know stuff happens, but that doesn't make it right. if i ever treated anyone like that, i would fire myself.
i hope you get your car soon and it is exactly what you want.
if there was a delay in your order because of the tragedy in Japan, your MA should have called you or emailed you. i'm not saying you deserve a ton of stuff for free because of the way you were treated, but you definitely don't deserve to be treated like that. you have the power and right to not do business with them anymore. if you don't like how you've been treated, exercise that and warn others.
i've bought new and used cars, cheap and expensive, and i've been treated like royalty. when i bought my mini, i felt like just another number. yes, they were attentive and willing to serve when i bought the car and wrote the check, but after they had it, they completely forgot about me. i had to go back multiple times just to get the floor mats.
i know stuff happens, but that doesn't make it right. if i ever treated anyone like that, i would fire myself.
i hope you get your car soon and it is exactly what you want.
#11
I agree with lonestarbuzz. If I recall from your prior posts, you car was ordered in late April - long before the supply issues with the auto trans were known. Stripes or not should not cause a delay like you've endured. I don't know what if any other changes you made and when, but if those caused additional delay it was your MA's job to advise you of that at the time you asked him/her to make them.
I don't like the tone of his/her emails and I don't think your request is unreasonable.
I don't like the tone of his/her emails and I don't think your request is unreasonable.
#12
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Vancouver Island, Canada
Posts: 3,334
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
The tone of the emails is a bit exasperated. Maybe the MA thought you were a bit of a pain in the ***, or maybe they are just overworked or having personal problems, or maybe they are just rude. It doesn't really matter. Bottom line, you are getting what you want, which is the dealer eating the cost of the stripes/labour. Don't push it any further, be gracious and take your car which will be exactly how you want it
#13
So here is the email I sent:
All of our conversations had been courteous until now, including during the ordering process.
BTW, the changes I made two weeks after my initial order:
Removed:
JCW Package
JCW Suspension
Parking sensor
MINI Connected
Added:
Sport Package
Sport suspension
Rear fog light
MINI Connected w/Nav (They told me Connected no Nav orders were being put on hold)
Thanks so much!
I'm sure I will be ecstatic when my car arrives.
-Eddie
I'm sure I will be ecstatic when my car arrives.
-Eddie
BTW, the changes I made two weeks after my initial order:
Removed:
JCW Package
JCW Suspension
Parking sensor
MINI Connected
Added:
Sport Package
Sport suspension
Rear fog light
MINI Connected w/Nav (They told me Connected no Nav orders were being put on hold)
#14
One question - when you deleted the stripes initially, did they reduce the price of the sport package? If they did, they're definitely being generous, with a little prodding, in eating their costs. If not, you've already paid for them, and either MINI eats any additional cost, or they'll split it with the dealer.
As for communicating with you about the delays because of the tragedy in Japan, it sounds like they really fell down on the job on that. My MA was very upfront in telling me early on (after I ordered, but when I was trying to find out when my car was scheduled to go into production) that Nav systems supply were causing delays, and that shortly after I ordered, they were told they couldn't take any more orders for Nav systems.
As for the overall tone of your MA's replies, he does seem a little snippy, but there could be many reasons for that. How much of a PITA have you really been?
As for communicating with you about the delays because of the tragedy in Japan, it sounds like they really fell down on the job on that. My MA was very upfront in telling me early on (after I ordered, but when I was trying to find out when my car was scheduled to go into production) that Nav systems supply were causing delays, and that shortly after I ordered, they were told they couldn't take any more orders for Nav systems.
As for the overall tone of your MA's replies, he does seem a little snippy, but there could be many reasons for that. How much of a PITA have you really been?
#15
One question - when you deleted the stripes initially, did they reduce the price of the sport package? If they did, they're definitely being generous, with a little prodding, in eating their costs. If not, you've already paid for them, and either MINI eats any additional cost, or they'll split it with the dealer.
As for communicating with you about the delays because of the tragedy in Japan, it sounds like they really fell down on the job on that. My MA was very upfront in telling me early on (after I ordered, but when I was trying to find out when my car was scheduled to go into production) that Nav systems supply were causing delays, and that shortly after I ordered, they were told they couldn't take any more orders for Nav systems.
As for the overall tone of your MA's replies, he does seem a little snippy, but there could be many reasons for that. How much of a PITA have you really been?
As for communicating with you about the delays because of the tragedy in Japan, it sounds like they really fell down on the job on that. My MA was very upfront in telling me early on (after I ordered, but when I was trying to find out when my car was scheduled to go into production) that Nav systems supply were causing delays, and that shortly after I ordered, they were told they couldn't take any more orders for Nav systems.
As for the overall tone of your MA's replies, he does seem a little snippy, but there could be many reasons for that. How much of a PITA have you really been?
I swear I've been pleasant. The only thing I've bothered him for in the past 8 weeks was the port my MINI would be shipped too. I did this through email and he never even got me the answer, I had to drive to the dealer and ask someone else.
#16
The tone of the emails is a bit exasperated. Maybe the MA thought you were a bit of a pain in the ***, or maybe they are just overworked or having personal problems, or maybe they are just rude. It doesn't really matter. Bottom line, you are getting what you want, which is the dealer eating the cost of the stripes/labour. Don't push it any further, be gracious and take your car which will be exactly how you want it
too many times people have these experiences, and too many times other people say "just deal with it, you're getting what you want anyway." it really doesn't make it right.
#17
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Vancouver Island, Canada
Posts: 3,334
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
while i agree with you about the end result, i don't agree that "it doesn't really matter." it's not about getting what you want, it's about getting what you want HOW you want. i could have the best product in the world, but if i'm a total douche when i talk to clients, i will never sell it.
too many times people have these experiences, and too many times other people say "just deal with it, you're getting what you want anyway." it really doesn't make it right.
too many times people have these experiences, and too many times other people say "just deal with it, you're getting what you want anyway." it really doesn't make it right.
For all we know (no offense to the OP as I'm not saying this is the case) the MA had a reason to be a little frustrated with the client.
#18
#19
Written communication really sucks as a means of truly understanding accurately what someone else means. There have been countless examples of miscommunication between two parties via email, text, etc. It is notoriously difficult to completely understand how something is being said without being able to hear and/or see someone say it. I think your response was right on the money. Better to be gracious at least until you receive your car, then you can let em' have it!
#20
I'm with you on this one, OP. While changing your order may have delayed the process a bit, it's your car to do with as you please. That said, I didn't like the way the guy you spoke with worded his emails either; they came off as "stop complaining, jerk. Maybe if you didn't change your mind so much, we wouldn't be in this mess," which I found unprofessional.
But I'm glad they threw in the stripes for free. Any sane dealership would have done the same. How much are stripes? Is it worth losing your customer loyalty? No.
But I'm glad they threw in the stripes for free. Any sane dealership would have done the same. How much are stripes? Is it worth losing your customer loyalty? No.
#21
Originally Posted by ACEkraut11
Better to be gracious at least until you receive your car, then you can let em' have it!
I'm with you on this one, OP. While changing your order may have delayed the process a bit, it's your car to do with as you please. That said, I didn't like the way the guy you spoke with worded his emails either; they came off as "stop complaining, jerk. Maybe if you didn't change your mind so much, we wouldn't be in this mess," which I found unprofessional.
But I'm glad they threw in the stripes for free. Any sane dealership would have done the same. How much are stripes? Is it worth losing your customer loyalty? No.
But I'm glad they threw in the stripes for free. Any sane dealership would have done the same. How much are stripes? Is it worth losing your customer loyalty? No.
#24
Little confused by this.
Don't worry, I'm not going to be making a big scene or anything after I get my car. I tend to avoid confrontations or uncomfortable situations. The worst I would do is tell the manager that he should talk to the MA about his email correspondence. There are much better ways to say what he was trying to say.
Don't worry, I'm not going to be making a big scene or anything after I get my car. I tend to avoid confrontations or uncomfortable situations. The worst I would do is tell the manager that he should talk to the MA about his email correspondence. There are much better ways to say what he was trying to say.
#25
Little confused by this.
Don't worry, I'm not going to be making a big scene or anything after I get my car. I tend to avoid confrontations or uncomfortable situations. The worst I would do is tell the manager that he should talk to the MA about his email correspondence. There are much better ways to say what he was trying to say.
Don't worry, I'm not going to be making a big scene or anything after I get my car. I tend to avoid confrontations or uncomfortable situations. The worst I would do is tell the manager that he should talk to the MA about his email correspondence. There are much better ways to say what he was trying to say.
Enjoy the car when you finally get it