Hi,
I read through the posts here and seems the only common issues are:
1. Transfer case leak. One at 30k replaced under warrany, and another a friend I know 150k
2. Water in the boot, just two people
3. Engine pulsing at 80F fixed with software, one
4. HUD two people
5. To motor mount
6. Car in limp mode presumed gforce sensor as happened turning right.
7. Powertrain flex disk, one person.

I probably missed some, but in summary hardly anything seems to break. The F56 B48 can have harmonic balancer at maybe 70k, oil filter cartridge housing oil leak at 100k (earlier for early builds apparently) that are not mentioned here. A few leaking injectors. And top motor mount.

Are there other things that are issues? I am considering moving from a F56 cooper to e 2021+ used Countryman. Seems to be about equal reliability.

Thanks for your time and consideration

 

I have owned mine for 2 years now and only issue was the engine mount on the pass side which is very common on these cars. 50k on it. Its considered a wear item?? Who new. I did replace the coupler for cracks but just because it has cracks in it does not mean it's faulty,

 

Our 17' is 7 yrs old, just hit 100K and the only thing that has needed replacing was the pass side motor mount, extended warranty took care of it. Just recently the roof sunshade needed replacing but that's because the wife broke it, so I don't really count that. Plus only one complete brake job (front /rear), normal wear and tear, and oil changes every 8-10K, we love this little CM!

 

Thank you both! I'll be trading my 23 White Silver Hardtop Cooper (not S) Signature 2.0 DCT 15,500 miles for a 23 Melting Silver Countryman 8 speed Signature 2.0 trim with 6300 miles. Has nav too. I think I lose heated steering wheel. Basically a $10k difference.