R56 Got Clubman S loaner during service some questions
#1
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Chicago Northern Suburbs
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Got Clubman S loaner during service some questions
Hey all,
I took my car for service today and they gave me 08 Clubman S auto.
I loved the car, but I have a few questions.
First off I really like that the floor in the boot is level with the seats when they fold.
It is an attachment that is like a foldable floor which goes into these rail that hold it. It can be taken out to have a normal floor, or it can be folded just to get access to the compartment created bellow.
I found this on RealOem
I'm talking about #3 which holds in place by #4.
So, is this available for a regular hardtop MCS?
If its not do you think it can be retrofitted from the clubman to the hardtop?
Is the cargo area/size/dimensions the same. I know clubman is larger, but isn't mostly due to the extra room for rear passengers?
Next question is about driving. I like the auto transmission but I cold not get used to the paddles. I cannot shift on time with them. I guess its just a matter of getting used to it.
What was strange for me is the accelerator pedal. It is as if it has 2 stages to it. I would floor it and it would go all the way down and I feel that it stopped, but then I can push it further and it's like an extra click or extra step or something and it goes about another half and inch, maybe less.
Is that an automatic transmission thing on these cars? Or is that something new? My 07 MCS manual does not do that.
Just some other observations. Love the power fold mirrors! I have cold weather but now power fold mirrors
I really like that when you press sport it shows up on display on the tach
Overall the car does not seem much bigger when driving. It is just as nimble and fun to drive
I took my car for service today and they gave me 08 Clubman S auto.
I loved the car, but I have a few questions.
First off I really like that the floor in the boot is level with the seats when they fold.
It is an attachment that is like a foldable floor which goes into these rail that hold it. It can be taken out to have a normal floor, or it can be folded just to get access to the compartment created bellow.
I found this on RealOem
I'm talking about #3 which holds in place by #4.
So, is this available for a regular hardtop MCS?
If its not do you think it can be retrofitted from the clubman to the hardtop?
Is the cargo area/size/dimensions the same. I know clubman is larger, but isn't mostly due to the extra room for rear passengers?
Next question is about driving. I like the auto transmission but I cold not get used to the paddles. I cannot shift on time with them. I guess its just a matter of getting used to it.
What was strange for me is the accelerator pedal. It is as if it has 2 stages to it. I would floor it and it would go all the way down and I feel that it stopped, but then I can push it further and it's like an extra click or extra step or something and it goes about another half and inch, maybe less.
Is that an automatic transmission thing on these cars? Or is that something new? My 07 MCS manual does not do that.
Just some other observations. Love the power fold mirrors! I have cold weather but now power fold mirrors
I really like that when you press sport it shows up on display on the tach
Overall the car does not seem much bigger when driving. It is just as nimble and fun to drive
#3
I notice one of those two-stage pedal (like a camera shutter button) on the Acura I drove on the weekend. I'm not sure if it's the same as the MINI, but on the Acura with an automatic, it was to force the transmission to downshift. So floor it all the way until it clicks to the floor, and it automatically downshift. Floor it, but not enough to "click" the second stage and... it just goes WOT. Not necessary on the manual transmission.
#4
Sounds like you didn't press the sport button -- sport mode affects both throttle and shift-point/speed on automatic.
I got a 09 328i loaner the other day. While overall the car is quite good, but that awfully laggy throttle in D mode drives me nut:
From a standing start, there is always 1+ secs delay before any power comes in, and you need at least press 1/4 throttle to show your commitment to the ECU. Then the auto start to downshift and you got overtaken by a branch of delivery vans and toyotas .
After half an hour of D mode, I had enough and switch to DS(Sport). Guess what? There is a lots of noise but still no real power until 5k rpm, and I end up use 3+ times as much fuel as my MCSa to cover the same route@same speed(~60mph).
On the other hand, 335i has virtually instant on power and no lag in D mode. NA engine should have less lag in theory but who knows what BMW has done to 328i.
I got a 09 328i loaner the other day. While overall the car is quite good, but that awfully laggy throttle in D mode drives me nut:
From a standing start, there is always 1+ secs delay before any power comes in, and you need at least press 1/4 throttle to show your commitment to the ECU. Then the auto start to downshift and you got overtaken by a branch of delivery vans and toyotas .
After half an hour of D mode, I had enough and switch to DS(Sport). Guess what? There is a lots of noise but still no real power until 5k rpm, and I end up use 3+ times as much fuel as my MCSa to cover the same route@same speed(~60mph).
On the other hand, 335i has virtually instant on power and no lag in D mode. NA engine should have less lag in theory but who knows what BMW has done to 328i.
#7
Trending Topics
#9
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Chicago Northern Suburbs
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yea, I know about that box, but its just not the same. The Clubman folding floor is just way more sophisticated.
I came across this some time ago, but it just seems too expensive
Although I think its better than the boot box and less expensive.
Now I wish someone came up with a good DIY for it.
I'm not crafty at all, so its not likely to be me
I came across this some time ago, but it just seems too expensive
Although I think its better than the boot box and less expensive.
Now I wish someone came up with a good DIY for it.
I'm not crafty at all, so its not likely to be me
#10
4th Gear
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Pocono Mountains
Posts: 514
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I want to know more about the Trunk Maker. Anybody have one? Will it support my 60 lb dog?
Has anyone created a template for a piece of wood that we might plop in there to serve as a level surface?
Some enterprising dude could make some serious money on this. MINI's charging $256.00 for the boot box that appears to collapse under any decent-sizzed load and the Trunk Master, although cheaper, is still waaaaay over-priced. Somebody with tool skills should be able to assemble something that would fit in back for under $20. Price it under $100 and you'd make a fortune.
Has anyone created a template for a piece of wood that we might plop in there to serve as a level surface?
Some enterprising dude could make some serious money on this. MINI's charging $256.00 for the boot box that appears to collapse under any decent-sizzed load and the Trunk Master, although cheaper, is still waaaaay over-priced. Somebody with tool skills should be able to assemble something that would fit in back for under $20. Price it under $100 and you'd make a fortune.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ECSTuning
Vendor Announcements
0
08-19-2015 12:51 PM
ECSTuning
Drivetrain Products
0
08-19-2015 08:22 AM
ECSTuning
Vendor Classifieds
0
08-19-2015 08:22 AM
ECSTuning
Drivetrain Products
0
08-14-2015 01:45 PM