Drivetrain 8 psi on GT28RS
#101
We want to know whats going on so we know what is happening and how to fix it. If you're having ignition problems, maxing out the injectors, blowing out the spark, running out of fuel pump, etc. etc. You keep answering with these tiny little simple sentences. Helping the community is mapping your journey, not just claiming things.
#102
I have to agree with a96bimmerm3, the posts are pretty much useless with the stuff you're giving us. We need some serious hard information with graphs, exact problems etc. We aren't trying to be mean by telling you this over and over like broken records. You might be taken more seriously though by just doing what we ask.
Last edited by jcap287; 04-18-2009 at 11:46 AM. Reason: changed your to you're
#103
I have to agree with a96bimmerm3, the posts are pretty much useless with the stuff you're giving us. We need some serious hard information with graphs, exact problems etc. We aren't trying to be mean by telling you this over and over like broken records. You might be taken more seriously though by just doing what we ask.
This week sometime I'm going to meet up with him, I'm not as busy with school being almost done.
#104
It's not that I don't believe him, that doesn't matter. If you go for a drive and its fast thats lovely. It's just that this thread has been ABSOLUTELY useless to the community and board as a whole because he says "oh we have issues at 16psi." It would actually help to have the issues described and more detail then a 6 word post about his stuff and how its "almost running." If he doesn't understand whats going on with the car, I can understand, but even a list of the symptoms. It's getting old. I know I sound like a broken record, but come on! This is getting ridiculous.
#105
I've been reading all M3's threads and like many of you, know nothing. It is obvious from his posts that he didn't do well in school. It is also obvious he's not mechanically inclined thus the reason why he can't explain anything. (I'm talking theory of mechanics, not the ability to bolt some parts on)
You won't get an answer as to what exactly is wrong because he knows only what the tuner tells him. (ie. it's lean above a certain rpm, the fuel injectors aren't keeping up, etc, etc)
If he was in the "know" like some of you guys, he could give a better explanation of what is wrong and why. I'm sure the tuner will tell him what he needs to do next. It's going to be a lot of trial and error.
How do I know? Because he's going through the same crap I went through when I installed a blown bigblock in an S10 and kept the stock ECU. Or when I tried to tune a blown 306 in a Miata... or the time another miata was at the dyno for 8 months getting tuned!!! (still never got it, had to sell the sc separately)
I can turn a wrench, make parts with what materials I have, much like the rest of you guys... I've been doing it for almost 30 years.
Having said all this.... his explanations suck, his descriptions and inability to share with the community simply sucks.
What doesn't suck is he one of the first to achieve this. He's obviously going to run into problems. We can't get any of our famed tuners to retune a stock R56, how the hell do we expect someone to rewrite a tune for an engine that is demanding so much more than a stock R56?
I personally think you're going to be beating your head for quite a while.... I'll bet you're tuning for at least another month or so before you get it close. And even at that, you may not get it perfect.
Nonetheless, congrats on your efforts, try to keep everyone in the loop. There are some extremely knowledgeable and talented people on this forum that could help you get your beast running perfectly.
Good luck...
<off my soapbox>
Mark
You won't get an answer as to what exactly is wrong because he knows only what the tuner tells him. (ie. it's lean above a certain rpm, the fuel injectors aren't keeping up, etc, etc)
If he was in the "know" like some of you guys, he could give a better explanation of what is wrong and why. I'm sure the tuner will tell him what he needs to do next. It's going to be a lot of trial and error.
How do I know? Because he's going through the same crap I went through when I installed a blown bigblock in an S10 and kept the stock ECU. Or when I tried to tune a blown 306 in a Miata... or the time another miata was at the dyno for 8 months getting tuned!!! (still never got it, had to sell the sc separately)
I can turn a wrench, make parts with what materials I have, much like the rest of you guys... I've been doing it for almost 30 years.
Having said all this.... his explanations suck, his descriptions and inability to share with the community simply sucks.
What doesn't suck is he one of the first to achieve this. He's obviously going to run into problems. We can't get any of our famed tuners to retune a stock R56, how the hell do we expect someone to rewrite a tune for an engine that is demanding so much more than a stock R56?
I personally think you're going to be beating your head for quite a while.... I'll bet you're tuning for at least another month or so before you get it close. And even at that, you may not get it perfect.
Nonetheless, congrats on your efforts, try to keep everyone in the loop. There are some extremely knowledgeable and talented people on this forum that could help you get your beast running perfectly.
Good luck...
<off my soapbox>
Mark
#106
mtuning3 - what is the problem ? Let everyone know..
We are all here for the same reason and everyone loves what mtuning has done to his car thus far, him and Xalia in Greece are the only 2 to have shown us pictures and videos of a big turbo setup and its amazing however mtuning3 could share alot more info, regardless of his level of understanding, he will know why they cannot go past 16 psi.
PS Xalia is running 16psi on his gt2560r without tuning
We are all here for the same reason and everyone loves what mtuning has done to his car thus far, him and Xalia in Greece are the only 2 to have shown us pictures and videos of a big turbo setup and its amazing however mtuning3 could share alot more info, regardless of his level of understanding, he will know why they cannot go past 16 psi.
PS Xalia is running 16psi on his gt2560r without tuning
Last edited by coopman7; 04-19-2009 at 09:10 AM.
#107
the issue we having right now its passed 16psi the car cuts power aroud 5000rpm,but no ignition pull ,afr is good in the low 11,the trottle plate just closes half way?up to 16psi the car runs verry strong al the way up until the rev limiter and xalia runing with is gt 25 witout any kind of tuning is suicidle,the stock afr is creasy lean as it is but the gt 28 is making much more volume than the gt 25
#108
the issue we having right now its passed 16psi the car cuts power aroud 5000rpm,but no ignition pull ,afr is good in the low 11,the trottle plate just closes half way?up to 16psi the car runs verry strong al the way up until the rev limiter and xalia runing with is gt 25 witout any kind of tuning is suicidle,the stock afr is creasy lean as it is but the gt 28 is making much more volume than the gt 25
Have you logged maf values to see if the car is pegging the maf? Also, if the stock MAP sensor is anything like the vw it reads up to 24ish psi, it could be getting to the upper threshold of that and slamming shut. Hmmm. Any codes or DTCs?
#110
mtuning3 - what is the problem ? Let everyone know..
We are all here for the same reason and everyone loves what mtuning has done to his car thus far, him and Xalia in Greece are the only 2 to have shown us pictures and videos of a big turbo setup and its amazing however mtuning3 could share alot more info, regardless of his level of understanding, he will know why they cannot go past 16 psi.
PS Xalia is running 16psi on his gt2560r without tuning
We are all here for the same reason and everyone loves what mtuning has done to his car thus far, him and Xalia in Greece are the only 2 to have shown us pictures and videos of a big turbo setup and its amazing however mtuning3 could share alot more info, regardless of his level of understanding, he will know why they cannot go past 16 psi.
PS Xalia is running 16psi on his gt2560r without tuning
#111
You're a little late. When i wrote that Xalia was infact NOT tuned
If you were keeping up you would have known that by reading his thread over a month ago
Quoting something i wrote 2 months ago which was correct at the time of posting is a bit silly now isnt it
Xalia, if i remember correctly got tuned at minikinetics with the unichip on 9th May 2009, around 3 weeks after i wrote what i did...
Skipping to the last 3 posts i assume
Last edited by coopman7; 06-21-2009 at 09:42 AM.
#114
the issue we having right now its passed 16psi the car cuts power aroud 5000rpm,but no ignition pull ,afr is good in the low 11,the trottle plate just closes half way?up to 16psi the car runs verry strong al the way up until the rev limiter and xalia runing with is gt 25 witout any kind of tuning is suicidle,the stock afr is creasy lean as it is but the gt 28 is making much more volume than the gt 25
I have a Peugeot 207 GT with the same mods as mtuning3.
I have the same problem with my car. It's running to the rev limiter with 0,9 bar/about 13 PSI. Above that the trottle plate closes half way.
My tuner thinks that it's the mapcensor that is the problem, but he is not sure.
I will get back with information as soon I have found a solution for the problem.
/Jesper from Denmark
#115
the issue we having right now its passed 16psi the car cuts power aroud 5000rpm,but no ignition pull ,afr is good in the low 11,the trottle plate just closes half way?up to 16psi the car runs verry strong al the way up until the rev limiter and xalia runing with is gt 25 witout any kind of tuning is suicidle,the stock afr is creasy lean as it is but the gt 28 is making much more volume than the gt 25
Tester
#116
Hi I'm from Denmark
I have a Peugeot 207 GT with the same mods as mtuning3.
I have the same problem with my car. It's running to the rev limiter with 0,9 bar/about 13 PSI. Above that the trottle plate closes half way.
My tuner thinks that it's the mapcensor that is the problem, but he is not sure.
I will get back with information as soon I have found a solution for the problem.
/Jesper from Denmark
I have a Peugeot 207 GT with the same mods as mtuning3.
I have the same problem with my car. It's running to the rev limiter with 0,9 bar/about 13 PSI. Above that the trottle plate closes half way.
My tuner thinks that it's the mapcensor that is the problem, but he is not sure.
I will get back with information as soon I have found a solution for the problem.
/Jesper from Denmark
Being that you are in EU you shoudnt have a problem getting your car mapped but mtuning3's is US spec so is more difficult to tune.
Last edited by coopman7; 06-23-2009 at 02:57 AM.
#117
The solution is a remap The stock ecu map does not like the aggresivness of how the gt28rs brings on its boost, the ecu therefore closes the throttle to limit boost. If you have some sort of scan tool you can hook it up and watch your throttle input % so even if you have your foot at WOT the actual throttle opening will be closer to 30%. Only way to overcome this is a custom remap.
Being that you are in EU you shoudnt have a problem getting your car mapped but mtuning3's is US spec so is more difficult to tune.
Being that you are in EU you shoudnt have a problem getting your car mapped but mtuning3's is US spec so is more difficult to tune.
My car has the same problem as mtuning3. My car has been flashed 34 times, wish means that we have tried to solved the problem with 34 different maps but no luck.
I will let you know when my tuner has the time to fix the problem.
#118
Personally i wouldnt have went the big turbo route unless i was 110% that i had a custom tune available so i hope it works out for you guys Let us know how you get on!
#120
the issue we having right now its passed 16psi the car cuts power aroud 5000rpm,but no ignition pull ,afr is good in the low 11,the trottle plate just closes half way?up to 16psi the car runs verry strong al the way up until the rev limiter and xalia runing with is gt 25 witout any kind of tuning is suicidle,the stock afr is creasy lean as it is but the gt 28 is making much more volume than the gt 25
I know what you're problem is..
Sounds to me, you're maxing out your Map sensor...
I'll bet my car, the Mini's Map sensor is only a 2 bar map sensor
1 Bar atmosphere + 1 Bar of Boost
manufacturer has no reason to make it more... since they didn't expect to boost that high
most 1 Bar Map sensors Max out at ~1.1-1.15 Bar which Suprise suprise is 16.X Psi
what happens is when the Map sensor is pegged.. the Ecu is invoking Boost/Fuel cut.. which is a defense mechanism for the engine to protect itself from blowing up...
your only solution is Get a 3 Bar map sensor..and rescale the timing and fuel maps
but that sounds beyond the scope of the stock ECU tuning...
if U want more power.. u need to get a bigger Turbo that can push more CFM @ 1.1 Bar
or at least a larger Turbine on the current turbo to improve top end..
otherwise look at other areas to improve the Volumetric Effeciency of the motor such as Cams, cooling of intake charge, porting/polishing, 3 way valve job etc..
simply turning up the wick doesn't seem to be an option...
If you don't believe me... you can test it..
u need to to tap into the signal wire of Map sensor.. it will either be rising or reducing voltage
as boost goes up.. the sensor will climb towards 5V or 0 V
and 1.1 Bar is pegging ur sensor at it's maximum
if ur not comfortable splicing wires or the scan tool cannot read the sensor data
perhaps u can look up the part number online and find some tech. info on it.