Drivetrain The Always Up-to-Date Thread on Tuning 2011+ (N18) MINIs
#1351
If MINI wanted you to tune and mod their cars they wouldnt have made the ECU such a ***** to crack.
Not all cars are meant to be modded, not say you cant try and see. but as seen mini didnt leave much room for more power and the enhanced emissions controls on the new engine reduce its potential greatly.
Again, you are playing with fire. Not saying it cant be done but dont expect huge gains or huge supports. Most companies have dropped major support for it. Hence why there are limited turbo options, no standalone, rods/pistons only for R53 and Gen 1 R56. The market isnt there and obviously bmw doesnt seem to want people screwing with their tuning haha.
The longevity of these tunes is still to be seen.
Not all cars are meant to be modded, not say you cant try and see. but as seen mini didnt leave much room for more power and the enhanced emissions controls on the new engine reduce its potential greatly.
Again, you are playing with fire. Not saying it cant be done but dont expect huge gains or huge supports. Most companies have dropped major support for it. Hence why there are limited turbo options, no standalone, rods/pistons only for R53 and Gen 1 R56. The market isnt there and obviously bmw doesnt seem to want people screwing with their tuning haha.
The longevity of these tunes is still to be seen.
#1352
If MINI wanted you to tune and mod their cars they wouldnt have made the ECU such a ***** to crack.
Not all cars are meant to be modded, not say you cant try and see. but as seen mini didnt leave much room for more power and the enhanced emissions controls on the new engine reduce its potential greatly.
Again, you are playing with fire. Not saying it cant be done but dont expect huge gains or huge supports. Most companies have dropped major support for it. Hence why there are limited turbo options, no standalone, rods/pistons only for R53 and Gen 1 R56. The market isnt there and obviously bmw doesnt seem to want people screwing with their tuning haha.
The longevity of these tunes is still to be seen.
Not all cars are meant to be modded, not say you cant try and see. but as seen mini didnt leave much room for more power and the enhanced emissions controls on the new engine reduce its potential greatly.
Again, you are playing with fire. Not saying it cant be done but dont expect huge gains or huge supports. Most companies have dropped major support for it. Hence why there are limited turbo options, no standalone, rods/pistons only for R53 and Gen 1 R56. The market isnt there and obviously bmw doesnt seem to want people screwing with their tuning haha.
The longevity of these tunes is still to be seen.
#1353
#1354
RENNtech has done Mercedes for years. I would trust them, I have spoken to them personally on the phone about their tunes.
I would still go for a dyno tune over a canned tune.
And yes none of these tunes longevity have been tested, accept ETG.. lols. Surviving 10k miles tuned isnt the same as 100k miles tuned. And i know no one has put that mileage on there yet.
Granted i am sure some of these tunes are super conservative meaning not big gains for the price. I just like to get the most I can out my car hence my choice in tuning.
Knowing what i know now, I would have gotten the r53.
The second R56 generation will never see high HP ever, unless its built by MINI or given access to do so from MINI like WRC teams. Until then 200-210WHP is all i can see for these cars. JCWs seeing a little more. Granted the Gen 1 only sees a little more potential.
Bottom line. you want a tuners car go get an EVO or 240.
I would still go for a dyno tune over a canned tune.
And yes none of these tunes longevity have been tested, accept ETG.. lols. Surviving 10k miles tuned isnt the same as 100k miles tuned. And i know no one has put that mileage on there yet.
Granted i am sure some of these tunes are super conservative meaning not big gains for the price. I just like to get the most I can out my car hence my choice in tuning.
Knowing what i know now, I would have gotten the r53.
The second R56 generation will never see high HP ever, unless its built by MINI or given access to do so from MINI like WRC teams. Until then 200-210WHP is all i can see for these cars. JCWs seeing a little more. Granted the Gen 1 only sees a little more potential.
Bottom line. you want a tuners car go get an EVO or 240.
#1355
RENNtech has done Mercedes for years. I would trust them, I have spoken to them personally on the phone about their tunes.
I would still go for a dyno tune over a canned tune.
And yes none of these tunes longevity have been tested, accept ETG.. lols. Surviving 10k miles tuned isnt the same as 100k miles tuned. And i know no one has put that mileage on there yet.
Granted i am sure some of these tunes are super conservative meaning not big gains for the price. I just like to get the most I can out my car hence my choice in tuning.
Knowing what i know now, I would have gotten the r53.
The second R56 generation will never see high HP ever, unless its built by MINI or given access to do so from MINI like WRC teams. Until then 200-210WHP is all i can see for these cars. JCWs seeing a little more. Granted the Gen 1 only sees a little more potential.
Bottom line. you want a tuners car go get an EVO or 240.
I would still go for a dyno tune over a canned tune.
And yes none of these tunes longevity have been tested, accept ETG.. lols. Surviving 10k miles tuned isnt the same as 100k miles tuned. And i know no one has put that mileage on there yet.
Granted i am sure some of these tunes are super conservative meaning not big gains for the price. I just like to get the most I can out my car hence my choice in tuning.
Knowing what i know now, I would have gotten the r53.
The second R56 generation will never see high HP ever, unless its built by MINI or given access to do so from MINI like WRC teams. Until then 200-210WHP is all i can see for these cars. JCWs seeing a little more. Granted the Gen 1 only sees a little more potential.
Bottom line. you want a tuners car go get an EVO or 240.
#1356
Well for reliable cars, I only need 205whp and 230wtq. I could care less for more power. When I start doing track days it's about the driver and the suspension, not how much power I put down. Anyone can push the gas down in straight line. Once I have the tune from RennTech I will dyno the car sometime in September when the weather gets a bit cooler in Michigan.
I don't want any other car cause everyone here has it but not more than a couple of a few tuned MINIs.
I don't want any other car cause everyone here has it but not more than a couple of a few tuned MINIs.
#1357
Well for reliable cars, I only need 205whp and 230wtq. I could care less for more power. When I start doing track days it's about the driver and the suspension, not how much power I put down. Anyone can push the gas down in straight line. Once I have the tune from RennTech I will dyno the car sometime in September when the weather gets a bit cooler in Michigan.
I don't want any other car cause everyone here has it but not more than a couple of a few tuned MINIs.
I don't want any other car cause everyone here has it but not more than a couple of a few tuned MINIs.
#1358
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: terry@burgertuning.com
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Been away from the MINI scene for a few years but the new BMW engine has me intrigued. So I borrowed a customers 2013 Cooper S N18 for some exploratory piggyback tuning. I've made some interesting discoveries on the DME logic side and have found that the basic TMAP+MAP attenuation (2 sensor only) piggyback style tuning that most of these European piggyback box makers offer does not add any measurable amount of power to the N18. At least with the USA DME programming. I've worked up a different approach to piggyback tuning it and so far its working well. So far I've picked up around 2mph in the 1/4 on a mild Stage1 tune and there is plenty more in it. We'll see what the dyno says next week.
Anyway, I'm obviously very familiar with BMW turbo tuning, but not at all in the N18 loop. What are you guys putting down on a dynojet both stock and with these OBDII bench flash tunes available?
*** EDIT *** Had a chance to read through some of the posts on this thread and it looks like they do 170-180whp 100% stock and anywhere from 190whp to 220whp 100% stock with the bench flash tunes. Running anywhere from 15psi to 20psi tuned vs. ~12psi stock.
Last edited by Terry @ BMS; 06-22-2013 at 11:59 AM.
#1359
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: terry@burgertuning.com
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
This is precisely what I don't like. It's relying on the ECU's knock detection for everyday reliability when it's only designed to be a safe measure for intermittent and seldom situations.
A tune that adjusted maps, while voiding the warranty, isn't going to knock to begin with because it already has the proper spark curves and fuel trim as a base. Knock protection remains a safety net for when it's needed, just as intended.
A tune that adjusted maps, while voiding the warranty, isn't going to knock to begin with because it already has the proper spark curves and fuel trim as a base. Knock protection remains a safety net for when it's needed, just as intended.
#1360
Every platform is different. But with the N18 the trick of it is getting the DME to alter it's load target so that it runs from different parts of the already programmed factory mapping. That way you get the combination of higher boost, less timing, and richer air/fuel ratios that we're looking for.
Rut-Ro Rob's gonna flip... (again)
#1362
Hey guys,
Been away from the MINI scene for a few years but the new BMW engine has me intrigued. So I borrowed a customers 2013 Cooper S N18 for some exploratory piggyback tuning. I've made some interesting discoveries on the DME logic side and have found that the basic TMAP+MAP attenuation (2 sensor only) piggyback style tuning that most of these European piggyback box makers offer does not add any measurable amount of power to the N18. At least with the USA DME programming. I've worked up a different approach to piggyback tuning it and so far its working well. So far I've picked up around 2mph in the 1/4 on a mild Stage1 tune and there is plenty more in it. We'll see what the dyno says next week.
Anyway, I'm obviously very familiar with BMW turbo tuning, but not at all in the N18 loop. What are you guys putting down on a dynojet both stock and with these OBDII bench flash tunes available?
*** EDIT *** Had a chance to read through some of the posts on this thread and it looks like they do 170-180whp 100% stock and anywhere from 190whp to 220whp 100% stock with the bench flash tunes. Running anywhere from 15psi to 20psi tuned vs. ~12psi stock.
Been away from the MINI scene for a few years but the new BMW engine has me intrigued. So I borrowed a customers 2013 Cooper S N18 for some exploratory piggyback tuning. I've made some interesting discoveries on the DME logic side and have found that the basic TMAP+MAP attenuation (2 sensor only) piggyback style tuning that most of these European piggyback box makers offer does not add any measurable amount of power to the N18. At least with the USA DME programming. I've worked up a different approach to piggyback tuning it and so far its working well. So far I've picked up around 2mph in the 1/4 on a mild Stage1 tune and there is plenty more in it. We'll see what the dyno says next week.
Anyway, I'm obviously very familiar with BMW turbo tuning, but not at all in the N18 loop. What are you guys putting down on a dynojet both stock and with these OBDII bench flash tunes available?
*** EDIT *** Had a chance to read through some of the posts on this thread and it looks like they do 170-180whp 100% stock and anywhere from 190whp to 220whp 100% stock with the bench flash tunes. Running anywhere from 15psi to 20psi tuned vs. ~12psi stock.
I'd be excited to see what you come up with for the N18, especially in R60all4 trim. If you haven't already, once we pick up our CMS4, I'd be willing to assist in the development.
aaron
#1363
#1365
https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=76184&d=1370119963
#1366
Page 50 of this thread.
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...4&d=1370119963
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...4&d=1370119963
#1367
#1371
That's what I thought too.
As far as how much whp N18s getting, im sure more like 200-210whp is realistic. And for those with Stage 2 NM tune might be seeing a little more than that. We're waiting on Tony to get his dyno done to see what's the deal on the numbers from NM.
As far as how much whp N18s getting, im sure more like 200-210whp is realistic. And for those with Stage 2 NM tune might be seeing a little more than that. We're waiting on Tony to get his dyno done to see what's the deal on the numbers from NM.
#1373
#1374
Never touching a piggyback style tune. Never. RennTech has given me my quote, awaiting for my grandfathers car since he's leaving in Romania the first week of July. I work almost every day so I can't be out of commission.
#1375
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: terry@burgertuning.com
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Terry, it's been a long time since I've seen you on the forums. I used to be on e90post back in '07-'08 when you were coming onto the N54 scene. That was an adventure;-)
I'd be excited to see what you come up with for the N18, especially in R60all4 trim. If you haven't already, once we pick up our CMS4, I'd be willing to assist in the development.
aaron
I'd be excited to see what you come up with for the N18, especially in R60all4 trim. If you haven't already, once we pick up our CMS4, I'd be willing to assist in the development.
aaron
To start the Stage1 N18 tuning system would be simple (similar to an N54 JB+) but we also have a relatively advanced Stage2+ CAN based JB4 system with features like in dash gauge hijacking (showing boost in dash, for example), on the fly map switching, 1st & 2nd gear boost limiting, etc, that we could adapt down the road if demand justified it. The CAN based system is able to datalog timing, air/fuel, knock count, etc, all through the factory DME and even self tune itself to optimize performance and safety as you race around. I won't waste my time talking about the JB4 much as that would be a long way out for N18 owners I will say its one of the most popular BMW N54/N55 tunes in use today.
Last edited by Terry @ BMS; 06-22-2013 at 10:20 PM.