Drivetrain Will I fail smog testing with these mods?
#1
Will I fail smog testing with these mods?
Basicly I need to know what I can and can not get away with modding in California, one of the most strict emissions testing states that I know of. I have heard of some members on this forum say how they removed the second cat (catalytic converter) to improve exhaust flow, is this illegal or is it legal? What about the turbo downpipes with the delete installed, my smog will be due in August and don't want any surprises whether visual inspection or tailpipe tests!
Thanks in advance!
Systemlord
Thanks in advance!
Systemlord
#2
No first-hand knowledge but I would guess getting rid of either or both cats in Kalifornia would be illegal and possibly be found in a SMOG inspection. I deleted my 2nd cat and resonator at at WOT merging onto an interstate, the sent of the exhaust is a bit stronger than it was before I cut it out. I still have the stock downpipe and cat.
Last edited by yetti96; 05-31-2013 at 02:30 PM.
#3
Basicly I need to know what I can and can not get away with modding in California, one of the most strict emissions testing states that I know of. I have heard of some members on this forum say how they removed the second cat (catalytic converter) to improve exhaust flow, is this illegal or is it legal? What about the turbo downpipes with the delete installed, my smog will be due in August and don't want any surprises whether visual inspection or tailpipe tests!
http://www.epa.gov/OMS/cert/factshts/catcvrts.pdf
All vehicle emission or engine mods in CA require a CARB sticker or plaque.
http://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermk...es/amquery.php
Yes, even adding an aftermarket intake - without being CARB certified will cause you to fail smog, and pay a fine for illegal modification.
#4
Removing or modifying converters in North America is a federal crime (really).
http://www.epa.gov/OMS/cert/factshts/catcvrts.pdf
All vehicle emission or engine mods in CA require a CARB sticker or plaque.
http://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermk...es/amquery.php
Yes, even adding an aftermarket intake - without being CARB certified will cause you to fail smog, and pay a fine for illegal modification.
http://www.epa.gov/OMS/cert/factshts/catcvrts.pdf
All vehicle emission or engine mods in CA require a CARB sticker or plaque.
http://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermk...es/amquery.php
Yes, even adding an aftermarket intake - without being CARB certified will cause you to fail smog, and pay a fine for illegal modification.
#5
I believe as long as the Carb sticker is on the intake, that pipe will be fine. NM made sure the whole kit was legal in this state.
#6
There is no way on earth that you will pass a sniffer test without a cat. It will pass with the 1 cat in the downpipe, as all JCW's don't have the second cat in the exhaust.
Unless you have the CARB EO# on the intake,(or any other part or subsystem), if it doesn't look stock, it will fail visual. Heck, if the tech is having a bad day it may fail for no reason. They just don't care. If it fails, it goes to a referee, and they sort it out.
If I owned a shop in Cali, I would fire on the spot, any employee that passed a friend, or took shortcuts, or looked the other way... It's too big a penalty, to **** around with. (I may not agree with it, but that's the way that state is, so deal with it, or move...)
Unless you have the CARB EO# on the intake,(or any other part or subsystem), if it doesn't look stock, it will fail visual. Heck, if the tech is having a bad day it may fail for no reason. They just don't care. If it fails, it goes to a referee, and they sort it out.
If I owned a shop in Cali, I would fire on the spot, any employee that passed a friend, or took shortcuts, or looked the other way... It's too big a penalty, to **** around with. (I may not agree with it, but that's the way that state is, so deal with it, or move...)
#7
There is no way on earth that you will pass a sniffer test without a cat. It will pass with the 1 cat in the downpipe, as all JCW's don't have the second cat in the exhaust.
Unless you have the CARB EO# on the intake,(or any other part or subsystem), if it doesn't look stock, it will fail visual. Heck, if the tech is having a bad day it may fail for no reason. They just don't care. If it fails, it goes to a referee, and they sort it out.
If I owned a shop in Cali, I would fire on the spot, any employee that passed a friend, or took shortcuts, or looked the other way... It's too big a penalty, to **** around with. (I may not agree with it, but that's the way that state is, so deal with it, or move...)
Unless you have the CARB EO# on the intake,(or any other part or subsystem), if it doesn't look stock, it will fail visual. Heck, if the tech is having a bad day it may fail for no reason. They just don't care. If it fails, it goes to a referee, and they sort it out.
If I owned a shop in Cali, I would fire on the spot, any employee that passed a friend, or took shortcuts, or looked the other way... It's too big a penalty, to **** around with. (I may not agree with it, but that's the way that state is, so deal with it, or move...)
Regardless though it's still a failed test. You have to meet all the requirements.
Trending Topics
#8
Can they really see the cat on the downpipe that is hidden from the heatshield...I don't think so. And I can tell you from the pain in the butt it is to take it off that they will not be performing that task to see if it is under there. As far as the sniffer test, not sure if it means anything or not but I am not running a cat on the dp or the secondary cat and my car stinks.
#9
My truck failed a CA smog test on the visual - I had a Volant air-box instead of the stock unit - the tech noticed it right away. I found a stock air-box and installed it, but my truck didn't pass because I just changed the battery with a new one and the drive cycles needed to be performed. After a week doing the drive cycle step by step I finally cleared the codes and it passed. It's a real pain in California to mod your vehicle if the parts don't have a CARB sticker.
#10
#11
Are the smog requirements in Washington State the same as in California? Down here they are very strict and stuff that slides in other states don't always pass here.
#12
#13
You're probably right, it seemed like a pretty simple test when i went in. they didnt even put anything on the tailpipe, they just plugged into my obd2 sensor.
#14
California sends bogus vehicles to smog stations to see if they can bust shops that let things slide, so just about all the places are too scared of losing their smog license to take a change.
If I'm not mistaken California's vehicle emissions standards are the toughest in the country.
#15
They take it very serious in Ca - I got failed for a plastic box that housed my air cleaner before the supercharger - how much is that going to affect my smog control?
California sends bogus vehicles to smog stations to see if they can bust shops that let things slide, so just about all the places are too scared of losing their smog license to take a change.
If I'm not mistaken California's vehicle emissions standards are the toughest in the country.
California sends bogus vehicles to smog stations to see if they can bust shops that let things slide, so just about all the places are too scared of losing their smog license to take a change.
If I'm not mistaken California's vehicle emissions standards are the toughest in the country.
#17
Think this might fail me too. Guess I'll find out in a couple hours.
Is it hard to change it back to stock? I just picked up my Mini and haven't done any work on it yet. Looks easy though
#18
#19
I think you mean catless down pipe that is Carb approved? No one makes a carb approved catless down pipe.
On my FJCW, the second cat is not monitored so I removed that along with the resonator.
You can always just remove the second cat (if you have it) which just right after the flex pipe.
#21
#22
Well, I have 2 years left, so it doesn't bother me either way, but didn't realize smogging was such a PITA. I guess when you know shops/people it's easier to pass visual by overlooking that bit and then having stock dp on, I know I should pass fine.
#23
Very true. Even with a aftermarket dp, shouldn't be too hard to put the stock one back on. Does it suck? Yes, hassle every two years? Sure. But it shouldn't take no more than an hr or so.
#24
I know people here in CA and I have done, that put every think back to stock for the test and then put it back after. I have seen engines changed, Cams, heater intake/.carbs/injectors. It depends on how much time and money you have and want to spend. In the last few years they have roadside checks and the set up on on ramps to get the reading as you come on freeway, that supposedly is to check air quality. The roadside checks are for cheaters. I used to make my own pipes to replace the Cats on my cars until it just became to much of a hassle to replace them every year, not it not every year and I am to old and don't like getting on my back under the vehicle to change this them. One thing I didn't have to replace the CATs they would last the life of the vehicle and they did run better especially the small engined ones.
tom
tom
#25
I know people here in CA and I have done, that put every think back to stock for the test and then put it back after. I have seen engines changed, Cams, heater intake/.carbs/injectors. It depends on how much time and money you have and want to spend. In the last few years they have roadside checks and the set up on on ramps to get the reading as you come on freeway, that supposedly is to check air quality. The roadside checks are for cheaters.
tom
tom
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
larryd96
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
11
09-08-2015 05:01 AM