Drivetrain 2% crank pulley , Bigger is better!
#51
I understand your concerns about the pulley being an issue on the mini. That thread really does go over all the info that has be generated by the "non dampener" pulley.
I too like reading the Engine building books, but they have to be read very carefully. I have yet to see a decent book that pertains to engines built anytime in the last 10 years with FI. There are some good honda specific ones, but nothing like the books on carbs, and V8's.
This brings me to the book that told you never to take off the balancer, most likly it was talking about the older V8's. I would agree and say don't do this either. But for newer built engines that use very high quality forged cranks, that are balanced with in 10-20 grams, this isn't really as big an issue. The harmonics that CAN be produced and transmitted to the crank pulley are going to be dampened by the belts and accessories.
The ALTA lightened crank pulley is an aftermarket part, that is designed to give you more HP. If the 5-10WHP gain from the pulley isn't worth the difference POSSIBLE SLIGHT engine wear, then the crank pulley isn't for you. This can also be said about the SC pulley, and that it produces more boost which in turn produces more engine wear, and looses the factory warranty. If these are huge concerns of yours, maybe the SC pulley isn't for you, and intakes and exhaust are the safe modifications.
In the end, only time will tell. After a couple of years of people running crank pulleys, this will show how this part isn't a concern.
I too like reading the Engine building books, but they have to be read very carefully. I have yet to see a decent book that pertains to engines built anytime in the last 10 years with FI. There are some good honda specific ones, but nothing like the books on carbs, and V8's.
This brings me to the book that told you never to take off the balancer, most likly it was talking about the older V8's. I would agree and say don't do this either. But for newer built engines that use very high quality forged cranks, that are balanced with in 10-20 grams, this isn't really as big an issue. The harmonics that CAN be produced and transmitted to the crank pulley are going to be dampened by the belts and accessories.
The ALTA lightened crank pulley is an aftermarket part, that is designed to give you more HP. If the 5-10WHP gain from the pulley isn't worth the difference POSSIBLE SLIGHT engine wear, then the crank pulley isn't for you. This can also be said about the SC pulley, and that it produces more boost which in turn produces more engine wear, and looses the factory warranty. If these are huge concerns of yours, maybe the SC pulley isn't for you, and intakes and exhaust are the safe modifications.
In the end, only time will tell. After a couple of years of people running crank pulleys, this will show how this part isn't a concern.
#52
#55
#56
Originally Posted by MyPocketRocket
#62
#63
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
elverado
R56 :: Hatch Talk (2007+)
2
01-18-2022 02:51 AM
M7Speed
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
0
09-03-2015 07:48 AM