Official Automatic Transmission Owners' Club
#476
Automatic drone
The Alta catback will probably have more issues with drone as it is a full 3" system. Also I have heard mixed results on NAM about drone issues with the catback. The JCW system I think is only a 2.25" system so there is less likelihood for drone, but that does not mean it won't happen. My exhaust, which is basically the same as BostonR56S's as I copied his exhaust with his help, does not really have any drone issues. It can get loud around 3k rpm, but it is by no means drony, at least to my ears. It is a custom 2.5" system with Magnaflow parts. My experience with it is that it was pretty loud for about 2-3 days and then it started to quiet down as the exhaust broke in.
Davidoyo, so yours is custom but basically a catback Magnaflow? It appears from all I have read about it that the 2.5" is the way to go. I suspect you made your own to save a bunch of $$$$, kudos!!
I saw something a few people up this thread referring to changing 1/2 the tranny fluid??? Or did they mean changing the fluid in 1/2 the prescribed time on the maintenance schedule?
I appreciate all who have replied to my questons.
S.
#477
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Youngsville, NC, USA
Posts: 1,342
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Read an interesting post within a post I can't find it.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
#478
1/2 & 1/2
Read an interesting post within a post I can't find it.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
As far as brake fluid goes I think the condensate in the lines causing the slave cylinders to go south is something to consider. Bleeding the old fluid out and replacing is probably a good idea.
S.
#479
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Your Worst Nightmare :)
Posts: 3,880
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
hey S if U (or anyone else) springs for the JCW tuning kit, make sure and book a day at yr. local track if U can, and witness how that t/k will transform yr. car to the point that you WILL be able to outperform manual MCS's and, depending on the driver's experience, keep well up with the factory JCW cars. Remember, that unlike the manuals, there's no temp loss of boost between shifts. Zoom Zoom.
Also, do a search here or on YouTube of some Japanese dudes driving a bone stock MCSa around some track in Spain, smoking 3 hot German hatches AND a Honda S2000R (altho the S2000 prob wouldve won if given an additional lap.) FN HILARIOUS!
Also, do a search here or on YouTube of some Japanese dudes driving a bone stock MCSa around some track in Spain, smoking 3 hot German hatches AND a Honda S2000R (altho the S2000 prob wouldve won if given an additional lap.) FN HILARIOUS!
#480
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Your Worst Nightmare :)
Posts: 3,880
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Read an interesting post within a post I can't find it.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
Basically for years the guy has been changing the fluid
in his resevoirs for years, regardless of official intervals.
Just the resevoirs. Siphon it out, put new in.
That way you get some new that diffuses in there, but you
don't have to open the system/become a full time mechanic.
He changed 1/2, "1/2" not sure if it was really half. But basically,
empty the transmission from the drain. Measure exactly how much
came out. Refill the exact amount. This seems to solve the
lifetime fluid that everybody knows really isn't lifetime.
#481
MCSa/JCW
hey S if U (or anyone else) springs for the JCW tuning kit, make sure and book a day at yr. local track if U can, and witness how that t/k will transform yr. car to the point that you WILL be able to outperform manual MCS's and, depending on the driver's experience, keep well up with the factory JCW cars. Remember, that unlike the manuals, there's no temp loss of boost between shifts. Zoom Zoom.
Also, do a search here or on YouTube of some Japanese dudes driving a bone stock MCSa around some track in Spain, smoking 3 hot German hatches AND a Honda S2000R (altho the S2000 prob wouldve won if given an additional lap.) FN HILARIOUS!
Also, do a search here or on YouTube of some Japanese dudes driving a bone stock MCSa around some track in Spain, smoking 3 hot German hatches AND a Honda S2000R (altho the S2000 prob wouldve won if given an additional lap.) FN HILARIOUS!
I love the automatic for its quick shifts and with Mini they have the computer working for you in automatic downshifts without waiting for you to stop first.
I will try to find the Posts about the Mini driver smoking the others on te track.
S.
#482
I realize this drone issue should probably be in a different thread but hey, it's an Automatic! I really appreciate all who have responded to my droning question.
Davidoyo, so yours is custom but basically a catback Magnaflow? It appears from all I have read about it that the 2.5" is the way to go. I suspect you made your own to save a bunch of $$$$, kudos!!
S.
Davidoyo, so yours is custom but basically a catback Magnaflow? It appears from all I have read about it that the 2.5" is the way to go. I suspect you made your own to save a bunch of $$$$, kudos!!
S.
#484
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Youngsville, NC, USA
Posts: 1,342
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
I looked but could not find it. And I thought I had book marked it.
I am looking for the exact equivelent Toyota ATF and how
many quarts do you think a real flush would be.
I talked to a guy today that seems really competant. He says
he can flush the thing and refill it via the transmisison cooler lines.
$225 and that seems very reasonable to me. Including the
fluid but I wanted to double check.
Thanks.
I am looking for the exact equivelent Toyota ATF and how
many quarts do you think a real flush would be.
I talked to a guy today that seems really competant. He says
he can flush the thing and refill it via the transmisison cooler lines.
$225 and that seems very reasonable to me. Including the
fluid but I wanted to double check.
Thanks.
#485
Condor27596, that mechanic knows nothing about MINIS. There are no cooler lines that contain ATF fluid. You cannot do a typical flush. I wish we could. MINI is backward in that engine coolant is circulated thru the transmission! Here is a link to the transmission fluid partial drain fill thread where we explain how to do it.
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3151767
There is no real fill hole, you have to remove a bolt that is very hard to access. It is a royal PITA. The Toyota Fluid is T-IV and is the exact stuff already in the transmission and sold by MINI for $30 a quart when Toyota sells it for $4 or $5 a quart.
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3151767
There is no real fill hole, you have to remove a bolt that is very hard to access. It is a royal PITA. The Toyota Fluid is T-IV and is the exact stuff already in the transmission and sold by MINI for $30 a quart when Toyota sells it for $4 or $5 a quart.
Last edited by clutchless; 11-19-2010 at 11:35 AM. Reason: update
#486
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Youngsville, NC, USA
Posts: 1,342
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
WOW
THANKS
You saved the day.
I saw that and could not find it again.
I'm sure it will take me a long time myself.
But, I am very determined.
He of course advertised on the groupon.
I called him and talked to him 10 minutes.
No doubt my car would be ruined and he'd be like
uh uh uh, well, uh, it was like that already.
THANKS
You saved the day.
I saw that and could not find it again.
I'm sure it will take me a long time myself.
But, I am very determined.
He of course advertised on the groupon.
I called him and talked to him 10 minutes.
No doubt my car would be ruined and he'd be like
uh uh uh, well, uh, it was like that already.
#488
Having done 2 drain and fills, in my opinion you would probably just force the hose out of the hole and pump fluid everywhere and make a mess. It is a fragile seal between the hose and transmission, I get a tiny bit of seepage just pouring fluid. The hole is really small. I think a pump may dislodge the hose or make it leak more. I did twist the hose in a little to get a better seal on the threads, but it is not really screwed in well. There is a VW tool that screws in the hole, like a 6 inch pipe with threads on one end.
http://www.costplustools.com/Assenma...-_p_14884.html
It only works on first gen cars, there is not enough room on second gen cars to use it as the hoses etc above the hole block access for the pipe as it goes straight up and you need to get it at an angle. It is really a tight work area.
I have heard of some using a mechanical fluid/oil pump or maybe your windshield pump would work to pump ATF fluid back in thru the drain hole. The stand pipe that sets fluid level would let you pump in enough until it overflowed.
http://www.costplustools.com/Assenma...-_p_14884.html
It only works on first gen cars, there is not enough room on second gen cars to use it as the hoses etc above the hole block access for the pipe as it goes straight up and you need to get it at an angle. It is really a tight work area.
I have heard of some using a mechanical fluid/oil pump or maybe your windshield pump would work to pump ATF fluid back in thru the drain hole. The stand pipe that sets fluid level would let you pump in enough until it overflowed.
Last edited by clutchless; 11-23-2010 at 06:49 AM. Reason: another idea
#489
#493
You may have sticker shock on the cost of a new replacement one. Depending on the years and miles on your car, you may consider a used one.
http://www.uneedapart.com/used-mini-parts.php
However local transmission shops may have a better line on local parts. You should compare the resale value of the car v trans repair costs.
http://www.uneedapart.com/used-mini-parts.php
However local transmission shops may have a better line on local parts. You should compare the resale value of the car v trans repair costs.
#494
#495
Doggie paddle...
Count me in on the paddle crew. As of 11-18, I now own an 09 MCS Clubman auto in Shiny Silver Metallic.
I am waiting on my JCW tuning kit to come into my local MINI dealer.
Hopefully it will be here Monday for my Birthday
I use to have an 02 MSC that I put an intake, pulley, Milltek header - exhaust, swaybars, Yokohama Prada Spec II tires... Yah fun little car. Now 9 cars and 4 years latter I'm back in a MINI.
I am waiting on my JCW tuning kit to come into my local MINI dealer.
Hopefully it will be here Monday for my Birthday
I use to have an 02 MSC that I put an intake, pulley, Milltek header - exhaust, swaybars, Yokohama Prada Spec II tires... Yah fun little car. Now 9 cars and 4 years latter I'm back in a MINI.
#496
Toyota Transmission?
Condor27596, that mechanic knows nothing about MINIS. There are no cooler lines that contain ATF fluid. You cannot do a typical flush. I wish we could. MINI is backward in that engine coolant is circulated thru the transmission! Here is a link to the transmission fluid partial drain fill thread where we explain how to do it.
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3151767
There is no real fill hole, you have to remove a bolt that is very hard to access. It is a royal PITA. The Toyota Fluid is T-IV and is the exact stuff already in the transmission and sold by MINI for $30 a quart when Toyota sells it for $4 or $5 a quart.
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3151767
There is no real fill hole, you have to remove a bolt that is very hard to access. It is a royal PITA. The Toyota Fluid is T-IV and is the exact stuff already in the transmission and sold by MINI for $30 a quart when Toyota sells it for $4 or $5 a quart.
S.
#497
The RMW Tune lived up to and beyond my expectations. The only problem i have is keeping myself from speeding as it is very easy to go fast now. It is a much better bang for your buck than the JCW package IMO. I have nothing against the JCW package, but I just can't justify spending all that money for what you get.
#498
FNG here; haven't even prepared my Intro post as I thought I'd wait until I had a good pic or two of the '07 MCSa my wife and I brought home this weekend.
But add me to the list of auto transmission owners. I think it, and the Mini it's in, are absolutely fantastic. And this coming from a guy whose other ride is a 672rwhp supercharged V8.
But add me to the list of auto transmission owners. I think it, and the Mini it's in, are absolutely fantastic. And this coming from a guy whose other ride is a 672rwhp supercharged V8.