R50/53 R53 Coolant Tank Temperature Reduction
#1
R53 Coolant Tank Temperature Reduction
Poking around on NAM and reading some of the sound insulation threads, links lead me to a variety of products, some of which were applicable for heat insulation. So I thought, why not find something to put on the underside of the exhaust manifold shield to reflect heat away from the coolant reservoir? The theory behind the choice is to apply the product as close as possible to the primary heat source. The products I selected were from Design Engineering Incorporated (http://www.designengineering.com/), Floor and Tunnel Shield and Cool Tape.
I bought a handheld IR temperature sensor to take data from the following locations as indicated in the two images:
1 - exhaust manifold shield left
2 - exhaust manifold shield center
3 - exhaust manifold shield right
4 - tunnel shield
5 - coolant reservoir
6 - tube to coolant reservoir
I'm taking data after my commute to and from work. I'll stop, shut off the engine, pop the hood and take measurements. I will also take a few numbers with the engine running. My goal is to get at least 20 measurements per location since based on the numbers I have already recorded, they vary significantly. The numbers for the tube should be taken lightly since I could not get close enough to measure only the tube. I will provide averages and the variances when the collection is complete. I will apply the exhaust and tunnel shield and retake numbers from the same locations.
![](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/gallery/data/500/medium/heat_1_image.jpg)
![](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/gallery/data/500/medium/heat_2_image.jpg)
Inputs and comments are appreciated.
I bought a handheld IR temperature sensor to take data from the following locations as indicated in the two images:
1 - exhaust manifold shield left
2 - exhaust manifold shield center
3 - exhaust manifold shield right
4 - tunnel shield
5 - coolant reservoir
6 - tube to coolant reservoir
I'm taking data after my commute to and from work. I'll stop, shut off the engine, pop the hood and take measurements. I will also take a few numbers with the engine running. My goal is to get at least 20 measurements per location since based on the numbers I have already recorded, they vary significantly. The numbers for the tube should be taken lightly since I could not get close enough to measure only the tube. I will provide averages and the variances when the collection is complete. I will apply the exhaust and tunnel shield and retake numbers from the same locations.
![](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/gallery/data/500/medium/heat_1_image.jpg)
![](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/gallery/data/500/medium/heat_2_image.jpg)
Inputs and comments are appreciated.
#3
I hope so Phillip. It is cheap (~$50 for materials) and easy (only two bolts to remove the exhaust manifold shield) so why not? I figure to have tunnel shield material left over from the manifold, so I will eventually also cover the forward part of the MINI shield. I have a hunch it may lower temps incident to the console.
#5
What exactly are you trying to accomplish here? Changing the temperature of the overflow/expansion tank isn't going to affect the bulk temperature of the coolant that's actually flowing through the engine.
Or are you trying to protect the plastic bottle itself from heat? I know some of the reservoir bottles on the earlier cars were prone to cracking/leaking (not necessarily because of heat, though), but you already have one of the later bottles.
Or are you trying to protect the plastic bottle itself from heat? I know some of the reservoir bottles on the earlier cars were prone to cracking/leaking (not necessarily because of heat, though), but you already have one of the later bottles.
#6
What exactly are you trying to accomplish here? Changing the temperature of the overflow/expansion tank isn't going to affect the bulk temperature of the coolant that's actually flowing through the engine.
Or are you trying to protect the plastic bottle itself from heat? I know some of the reservoir bottles on the earlier cars were prone to cracking/leaking (not necessarily because of heat, though), but you already have one of the later bottles.
Or are you trying to protect the plastic bottle itself from heat? I know some of the reservoir bottles on the earlier cars were prone to cracking/leaking (not necessarily because of heat, though), but you already have one of the later bottles.
Like I said, this is a cheap and easy process. I figure it is not a bad idea to reflect heat away from the aft engine compartment.
#7
Trending Topics
#8
#9
#10
#12
Not yet, but I do have some data for folks to chew on.
The chart below shows data points (with high and low values removed) for the engine running for the 6 locations shown in the first post. There were 13 sets of data taken, so the plot shows 11. The plot is location temperature (recorded by a handheld IR temperature gun) versus outside temperature (reported by the gauge in the car). Statistics are also provided for the outside temperature and the 6 data locations.
I am only gonna make some general observations based on the statistics. The temps did not seem to be proportional to the outside temperature. Not surprisingly, the highest temps were on the manifold shield. I was surprised that the right side of the shield was consistently hotter than the other shield locations. The shield data was also the most varied, with the highest standard deviations. The coolant reservoir and the tube recorded the most stable temps.
The chart below shows data points (with high and low values removed) for the engine running for the 6 locations shown in the first post. There were 13 sets of data taken, so the plot shows 11. The plot is location temperature (recorded by a handheld IR temperature gun) versus outside temperature (reported by the gauge in the car). Statistics are also provided for the outside temperature and the 6 data locations.
I am only gonna make some general observations based on the statistics. The temps did not seem to be proportional to the outside temperature. Not surprisingly, the highest temps were on the manifold shield. I was surprised that the right side of the shield was consistently hotter than the other shield locations. The shield data was also the most varied, with the highest standard deviations. The coolant reservoir and the tube recorded the most stable temps.
![](http://img149.imageshack.us/img149/4453/beforetempdataimagemj4.th.jpg)
#13
Hmmm. Very interesting. Good science. Shows me very little tendency for the coolant to boil(?) -- Please correct me if I'm off base on that conclusion!!
If you plan to do more measuring in higher ambient temps, I would find it interesting also. Most of your observations are in what I would consider, as a SoCal resident, on the "cool" side. My system frequently loses coolant and turns the fan on due to what I think of as "overheating," even though I have the M7 aerogel heat shield (over the header in the rear of the engine bay). I have been concerned that it actually does not help due to reducing air flow, but I have not devised an experiment that would help to determine the "truth."
I have a tune that I know runs the car a bit leaner than stock, but I'm not sure what sort of exhaust temps or AFR's I am actually reaching on the high side.
I need more gauges!!
If you plan to do more measuring in higher ambient temps, I would find it interesting also. Most of your observations are in what I would consider, as a SoCal resident, on the "cool" side. My system frequently loses coolant and turns the fan on due to what I think of as "overheating," even though I have the M7 aerogel heat shield (over the header in the rear of the engine bay). I have been concerned that it actually does not help due to reducing air flow, but I have not devised an experiment that would help to determine the "truth."
![Confused](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/images/smilies/confused.gif)
I have a tune that I know runs the car a bit leaner than stock, but I'm not sure what sort of exhaust temps or AFR's I am actually reaching on the high side.
![Frown](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/images/smilies/frown.gif)
I need more gauges!!
![Grin](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/images/smilies/grin.gif)
#14
Hmmm. Very interesting. Good science. Shows me very little tendency for the coolant to boil(?) -- Please correct me if I'm off base on that conclusion!!
If you plan to do more measuring in higher ambient temps, I would find it interesting also. Most of your observations are in what I would consider, as a SoCal resident, on the "cool" side. My system frequently loses coolant and turns the fan on due to what I think of as "overheating," even though I have the M7 aerogel heat shield (over the header in the rear of the engine bay). I have been concerned that it actually does not help due to reducing air flow, but I have not devised an experiment that would help to determine the "truth."
If you plan to do more measuring in higher ambient temps, I would find it interesting also. Most of your observations are in what I would consider, as a SoCal resident, on the "cool" side. My system frequently loses coolant and turns the fan on due to what I think of as "overheating," even though I have the M7 aerogel heat shield (over the header in the rear of the engine bay). I have been concerned that it actually does not help due to reducing air flow, but I have not devised an experiment that would help to determine the "truth."
![Confused](https://www.northamericanmotoring.com/forums/images/smilies/confused.gif)
I also do wish that temps were higher, but I want to put the material on now, just to finish the project. If I had a spare manifold shield, I could easily record more baseline temps when the weather gets hotter.
#16
#18
TOO COOL!!
I look forward to it. PM me when you're set. I'm off from this Saturday- 1/6.
#19
I finally put the material on, the before and after images of the underside of the exhaust manifold shield are shown below. If nothing else, it looks a lot shinier! The material adds less than 1/4" thickness to the shield. It didn't take long, but its nice to be able to take your time and do a job right. I'll start data logging this week and when I get a similar number of data points to the compare with the before case, I will post them.
![](http://img153.imageshack.us/img153/1393/shieldbeforeqj6.th.jpg)
![](http://img153.imageshack.us/img153/5960/shieldafterle6.th.jpg)
#20
Phase 1 Results
...finally!
The chart shows the data plotted in the same way as the baseline (Before) set. The table below repeats the baseline statistics, shows the numbers with the heat shield treatment, and lists the deltas (delta = after - before). I am pleased to report that there was a measureable reduction in the coolant tank temperature (column 5), an average of 9 deg F. The temps on the right side of the exhaust manifold shield were knocked down a lot, 82 deg F (column 3). I have nary a clue why the center and left heat shield temps were not reduced to a similar extent. Additionally, the standard deviation was less for the coolant tank temps with the treated heat shield.
Lastly, I am going to put the same heat reflection material on the front part of the tunnel shield to see if there is any further benefit. The minimum coolant tank temperature should be the temperature of the coolant itself. As the days grow hotter, I will take more readings to get an idea of temps under extreme conditions.
The chart shows the data plotted in the same way as the baseline (Before) set. The table below repeats the baseline statistics, shows the numbers with the heat shield treatment, and lists the deltas (delta = after - before). I am pleased to report that there was a measureable reduction in the coolant tank temperature (column 5), an average of 9 deg F. The temps on the right side of the exhaust manifold shield were knocked down a lot, 82 deg F (column 3). I have nary a clue why the center and left heat shield temps were not reduced to a similar extent. Additionally, the standard deviation was less for the coolant tank temps with the treated heat shield.
Lastly, I am going to put the same heat reflection material on the front part of the tunnel shield to see if there is any further benefit. The minimum coolant tank temperature should be the temperature of the coolant itself. As the days grow hotter, I will take more readings to get an idea of temps under extreme conditions.
![](http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/3910/afterv1copycb4.th.jpg)
#21
3rd Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Greenville NC
Posts: 159
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My goal is simply to reduce the heat from the exhaust manifold into the engine compartment. I realize the coolant temperature is not going to change. I appreciate the information on the coolant reservoir itself, I was not aware of that change.
Like I said, this is a cheap and easy process. I figure it is not a bad idea to reflect heat away from the aft engine compartment.
Like I said, this is a cheap and easy process. I figure it is not a bad idea to reflect heat away from the aft engine compartment.
![](http://images116.fotki.com/v721/photos/7/7305/4257627/Enginecomparo-vi.jpg)
Last edited by Modshack; 02-10-2008 at 04:35 PM.
#22
#23
Modshack, this was a what-if exercise. I had no idea what to expect for temperature reduction. As you can see though, the application of the DEI material to the heatshield reduced the temperature of the coolant reservoir.
Your idea is very interesting also. Have you done this on a MINI? Is there any rattle with the hood?
Your idea is very interesting also. Have you done this on a MINI? Is there any rattle with the hood?
#24
3rd Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Greenville NC
Posts: 159
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Modshack, this was a what-if exercise. I had no idea what to expect for temperature reduction. As you can see though, the application of the DEI material to the heatshield reduced the temperature of the coolant reservoir.
Your idea is very interesting also. Have you done this on a MINI? Is there any rattle with the hood?
Your idea is very interesting also. Have you done this on a MINI? Is there any rattle with the hood?
#25
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Kimolaoha
R56 :: Hatch Talk (2007+)
70
07-05-2023 01:04 PM
ebowling
R50/R53 :: Hatch Talk (2002-2006)
90
08-04-2019 09:15 AM
tylewis
R56 :: Hatch Talk (2007+)
4
08-18-2015 06:53 AM
PSIChocolate
Stock Problems/Issues
1
08-13-2015 12:46 PM