R55 Clubman Reliability
#53
#55
Had a few problems myself with only 16000km's but all dealer fixed, warranty or recall. Window dipper, new catalytic converter, new chain tensioner and new manifold/drain to stop throttle body from freezing due to condensation. Just keep an eye on things and check for any recalls and you should be fine.
By the way, I'm having an Alta CAI installed as we speak and had a checkered roof graphic installed on my sunroof.
By the way, I'm having an Alta CAI installed as we speak and had a checkered roof graphic installed on my sunroof.
#59
Just placed my order - will make my 1k initial deposit tomorrow. :-)
Clubman S, PW with Black Roof, Pillars, and moon/sun Roof
Nav, Brown LOUNGE Leather Interior, Sat Radio, and some other goodies.
The build is being submitted as I type this - I won't feel like it's official till it's on the boat, and I"ve got a buyer for my 2004 scion xb (any takers?) :-D
I'm excited, about to do the happy dance.
jeff
p.s. look for a new screenname from me in 6-8 weeks ;-)
Clubman S, PW with Black Roof, Pillars, and moon/sun Roof
Nav, Brown LOUNGE Leather Interior, Sat Radio, and some other goodies.
The build is being submitted as I type this - I won't feel like it's official till it's on the boat, and I"ve got a buyer for my 2004 scion xb (any takers?) :-D
I'm excited, about to do the happy dance.
jeff
p.s. look for a new screenname from me in 6-8 weeks ;-)
#60
Guest
Posts: n/a
Ooooo...brown leather... I have Tuscan Gravity (so I can spill my iced coffee and never see a stain! ), and although I'm prolly doing it all wrong, I just use a damp-wrung microfiber towel to clean, followed by a leather wipe (like Wet Ones) by Meguires I picked up at Target. It claims no lanolin, but has conditioners and UV protectant, and the seats look great for 3-4 weeks after treatment. When they start looking dry, they get a cleaning and treatment, and of course they still look brand new. Congrats, Jeff...you have chosen wisely! (BTW, I keep a few 'white-trash' seatcovers handy: In-N-Out T-shirts, for when I'm too dirty/sweaty to sit on my leather seats...helps keep'em clean.
#61
#64
Actually, it’s an 04, 130k miles, lowered on espelir springs (1.5 inch) with stock rims. Got chrome trim rings and wheel caps so it’s bling on a budget. AEM intake, trd exhaust – and a few dings in the window/body from 130k miles of lovin :-D
#65
I have had my Clubman for a little under a year. We are fast approaching 30k miles on it. So far it has been a really good car for us. We have had no more problems with the car than we expected. you do have to remember that this is not a Civic. I went into it with the mind set that this is more of a premium/sports car and will have some minor problems that other cars wont.
So far the only problem that the car has had was the window dipper problem. The dealership fixed it with out any problems.
So far the only problem that the car has had was the window dipper problem. The dealership fixed it with out any problems.
#66
Should I go for it?
Been shopping around for a Mini Cooper Clubman for a while and haven't found the perfect new one and I need a car ASAP (Old car was totaled 3 weeks ago, and I have to give up rental soon.). The dealer has a 2008 with low miles and every option I want. Salesman just faxed over service records and it turns out the cable harness was replaced. Otherwise no other problems. Should I be worried?
#67
Well no, I’d say it’s more box or toaster shaped. It looks like a mix between a box, a toaster, and possibly…POSSIBLY a cube :-P
Actually, it’s an 04, 130k miles, lowered on espelir springs (1.5 inch) with stock rims. Got chrome trim rings and wheel caps so it’s bling on a budget. AEM intake, trd exhaust – and a few dings in the window/body from 130k miles of lovin :-D
Actually, it’s an 04, 130k miles, lowered on espelir springs (1.5 inch) with stock rims. Got chrome trim rings and wheel caps so it’s bling on a budget. AEM intake, trd exhaust – and a few dings in the window/body from 130k miles of lovin :-D
The other xB is just a stock 08 Super White.
(sorry...I'm going off topic)
#68
Miniclubwoman, I say go for it. Dealers generally don't hold onto used cars that aren't good sellers, so I suspect that if they didn't think it was a good unit, they would've auctioned it off. The other thing is that it still has a good amount of the original warranty left, so that alone should give you peace of mind.
Last edited by jcoop36; 07-02-2009 at 03:04 PM. Reason: typo
#69
Guest
Posts: n/a
Been shopping around for a Mini Cooper Clubman for a while and haven't found the perfect new one and I need a car ASAP (Old car was totaled 3 weeks ago, and I have to give up rental soon.). The dealer has a 2008 with low miles and every option I want. Salesman just faxed over service records and it turns out the cable harness was replaced. Otherwise no other problems. Should I be worried?
#72
#73
I had my first experience with the club door sticking a few nights ago. It wasn't particularly cold or hot, just average temperature and maybe a little bit of humidity. The handle stuck the first two times I pulled it, then worked normally the third time. I used the door a few more times that night with no problems, and it hasn't stuck since.
#74
Nice - so Mini with HID's ($500) ftw, and might go for the cream/beige enterior which is $500 less or so too, sweet thanks
anybody got pics of the mini OEM hid/halogen bulbs by chance?
Thanks again, and sorry for being all over the place with this post.
looking to order this week, W00T!
anybody got pics of the mini OEM hid/halogen bulbs by chance?
Thanks again, and sorry for being all over the place with this post.
looking to order this week, W00T!
#75
Hey folks
As I read more into the threads here, however, it seems the reliability on the coopers and clubmans sucks. 4/10 on some major car sites - and it seems quite a few of you have issues with club doors, melting hood scoops, and other stuff that should not be a problem for a 30k(give or take) car.
As I read more into the threads here, however, it seems the reliability on the coopers and clubmans sucks. 4/10 on some major car sites - and it seems quite a few of you have issues with club doors, melting hood scoops, and other stuff that should not be a problem for a 30k(give or take) car.
Consumer Reports, on the other hand, collects actual feedback from owners from all makes and models and compares them. Although you won't actually know reliability on the 2009s until they get their next survey back, the 2008s did very well, with only one car in its classed having a higher predicted reliability, the Toyota Matrix. The Clubman beat out similar cars from Subaru, Mazda, Kia, Chevrolet, Chrysler, Pontiac, Scion, and Volvo with a rating of 80% more reliable than average.
http://consumerreports.com
Note that the reliability of all of the models isn't uniform, and the ratings are updated every year as more data comes in. For example, as a used car the 2002 MINI Cooper has poor reliability compared to similar cars in the same year.
If you have a more scientific source with more reliable data I'd like to know about it!