R56 Why did they change the engine from a...
#76
The N54 engine that powers the 335 and now 535 has had some teething pains.
Having said that, regardless of why Mini went to the TC mill, the R56 engine is a nice unit. As time progresses, it should show an ability to take well to mods.
While I am a fan of the R53, some of you seem to be forgetting the horrendous ECU issues that we had over the years - how many flashes did we have to endure to make things right? It wasn't until the end of the production run that BMW finally got close to getting it right.
Hopefully the early reports of BMW having issues wringing more horsepower reliably out of the Prince engine will prove to be false. One big plus for the Tritec was that it was fairly bulletproof and handled mods and big hp gains well.
Time will tell whether or not the Prince will do as well in this regard.
#77
I'm incredibly impressed with the initial reliability of the R56 mill, especially since it is a clean-sheet design in its first year and full of high-tech goodies that are relative novelties in the BMW realm and in all of cardom. All reported problems have been relatively minor in scope (nothing like the S54, which was prone to catastrophic, explosive failure in its first year or, like Skiploder mentioned, the 02-03 SC). While it may be more generic, there is a reason for the newfound proliferation of small, twin-scroll turbocharging, especially when paired with direct-injection - unparalleled efficiency!
#78
The old engine & gearbox was bullet proof, the turbo has issues , it can sound like a diesel engine on cold mornigs, the clutch/ gearbox has inherant problems on early models . Mine has this problem & is going in to morrow for the 5 th diffent thing since the 1st March, yes its the gearbox thing. If they dont get it right this time iam rejecting it.
#79
#80
The old engine & gearbox was bullet proof, the turbo has issues , it can sound like a diesel engine on cold mornigs, the clutch/ gearbox has inherant problems on early models . Mine has this problem & is going in to morrow for the 5 th diffent thing since the 1st March, yes its the gearbox thing. If they dont get it right this time iam rejecting it.
And the dieseling sound... good luck getting rid of that. It's been well documented that its the common-rail DFI system ticking away... that is, unless you've joined the BMW conspirocy theorists and are now conviced that the engine is about the blow. Be pretty hard to get rid of it. There's only been one case over on MINI2 of an engine rattle that turned out to be anything of note.
#81
The old engine & gearbox was bullet proof, the turbo has issues , it can sound like a diesel engine on cold mornigs, the clutch/ gearbox has inherant problems on early models . Mine has this problem & is going in to morrow for the 5 th diffent thing since the 1st March, yes its the gearbox thing. If they dont get it right this time iam rejecting it.
#82
Supercharged sounds nicer in my opinion, (with the help of a CAI and smaller pulley), but it is parasitic, because the engine must sacrifice some power in order to turn the supercharger.
The Turbo allows for much higher power gains, which are not parasitic.
Turbo is the wave of the future, and the easiest way to huge horsepower numbers.
The Turbo allows for much higher power gains, which are not parasitic.
Turbo is the wave of the future, and the easiest way to huge horsepower numbers.
#83
Agreed... there is lag. The power also ends abruptly... all characteristics of turbo charged motors. They do tend to have higher fuel efficently... but so do hybrids. I do admit the thought of a diesel MINI would be very appealing... it would offer signifigant fuel savings.
#84
let go of the past. r53 is the past. just look how long it took for bmw to come back to turbo engines. 20 years or so? hang around for another 25 years or so and they might go back to superchargers.
#85
sounds like a diesal - So? Those are direct injectors.
trans.. does the term "midlands" mean anything to you? everyone who has that tranny has a less than stellar trans.
Sorry that you have a problem with your trans.. it is a very small percentage of the whole however.
#86
2nd Gear
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2007
Location: MetroPlex, TX
Posts: 110
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As some of us already know, the 07 MCS engine is the same as the new Peugeot 207 GTI.
Does anyone know if this was a "joint venture" or if it was a simply BMW purchasing the engines from the PSA group (I'm sure there will be a Citroen using the same engine too) and recalibrating the ECU etc for its implimentation in the Mini ?
Either way, any european will know that Peugeot has an excellent record of making great small displacement performance engines. They have a HUGE amount of experience with turbos, mostly with there awesome diesel engines.
Also, I noted that there is a Mini Cooper D (turbo) in Europe http://www.mini.co.uk/html/model_ran.../techSpec.html
Does anyone know if this was a "joint venture" or if it was a simply BMW purchasing the engines from the PSA group (I'm sure there will be a Citroen using the same engine too) and recalibrating the ECU etc for its implimentation in the Mini ?
Either way, any european will know that Peugeot has an excellent record of making great small displacement performance engines. They have a HUGE amount of experience with turbos, mostly with there awesome diesel engines.
Also, I noted that there is a Mini Cooper D (turbo) in Europe http://www.mini.co.uk/html/model_ran.../techSpec.html
Last edited by ukaussi; 05-21-2007 at 08:32 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Kimolaoha
R56 :: Hatch Talk (2007+)
70
07-05-2023 01:04 PM