R56 DD/HS Build Thread
#53
OVERDRIVE
iTrader: (1)
I would not think that the short trips would do that. Our Cooper only does short trips and have never had an issue. As long as there is water in the tank, you won't have a problem with overheating. Check it tomorrow and see how it does at the end of the day, then decide about the autoX. If you do the autoX, just watch it, as you said; I would be doing that anyway.
BTW - Do you have a scangageII so you can watch the engine temp? If not, get one from Autozone or the like and put it in before you go autoX. It is an easy install.
BTW - Do you have a scangageII so you can watch the engine temp? If not, get one from Autozone or the like and put it in before you go autoX. It is an easy install.
#54
I would not think that the short trips would do that. Our Cooper only does short trips and have never had an issue. As long as there is water in the tank, you won't have a problem with overheating. Check it tomorrow and see how it does at the end of the day, then decide about the autoX. If you do the autoX, just watch it, as you said; I would be doing that anyway.
BTW - Do you have a scangageII so you can watch the engine temp? If not, get one from Autozone or the like and put it in before you go autoX. It is an easy install.
BTW - Do you have a scangageII so you can watch the engine temp? If not, get one from Autozone or the like and put it in before you go autoX. It is an easy install.
#55
OVERDRIVE
iTrader: (1)
I run with it all of the time. I have it set to read volts, pressure (turbo), oil temp and water temp. Best set of gauges...
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ni-cooper.html
PS - sorry you don't have oil temp in the earlier Gen IIs
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ni-cooper.html
PS - sorry you don't have oil temp in the earlier Gen IIs
Last edited by Eddie07S; 04-18-2013 at 07:56 PM. Reason: edit
#56
Better measure timing chain slack ASAP. If it is more than 68 mm, but less than 70 mm, install the "long" tensioner (easy/cheap). If more than 70 mm, replace entire timing chain system (expensive). You are at the critical mileage for a Justa. Not much racing happens with no motor.......
Please post results/outcome.
DOC
Please post results/outcome.
DOC
#58
Better measure timing chain slack ASAP. If it is more than 68 mm, but less than 70 mm, install the "long" tensioner (easy/cheap). If more than 70 mm, replace entire timing chain system (expensive). You are at the critical mileage for a Justa. Not much racing happens with no motor.......
Please post results/outcome.
DOC
Please post results/outcome.
DOC
Also, not sure how to measure the slack... I bought a Justa to avoid this problem... No other symptoms of a timing chain problem btw, no rattle or anything.
Last edited by kyoo; 04-18-2013 at 08:08 PM.
#59
Timing chain has nothing to do with coolant loss.
I also haven't heard that the Justa's were having the same timing chain issues as the s models.
However, changing the tensioner is a fairly easy job, it just unscrews from the back passenger side of the head, and a new one goes in.
I think you may have a head gasket issue, if you're not seeing any puddling under the car. Is there any noticable leakage? Any smell of coolant when it runs?
I also haven't heard that the Justa's were having the same timing chain issues as the s models.
However, changing the tensioner is a fairly easy job, it just unscrews from the back passenger side of the head, and a new one goes in.
I think you may have a head gasket issue, if you're not seeing any puddling under the car. Is there any noticable leakage? Any smell of coolant when it runs?
#61
My post was not in response to your coolant loss issue (water pump?), but rather to your impending motor loss. Justas DO have catastrophic failures due to excessive timing chain slack. Due to various factors, it just takes more miles than on an N14. (All the same design/parts.) When you get over 72 mm, the OEM tensioner can no longer control the slack, teeth get skipped and no more autocrosses.
You can follow the Bentley manual instructions or Service Bulletin SI M11 02 07 to do it yourself, or have a dealer do it. It takes 30 min to check slack and replace the tensioner. I paid $35 at the parts counter at my dealer for the "long" tensioner.
Pay particular attention to my posts in the following thread:
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...0-minis-6.html
(I am a Justa owner. See sig.)
DOC
You can follow the Bentley manual instructions or Service Bulletin SI M11 02 07 to do it yourself, or have a dealer do it. It takes 30 min to check slack and replace the tensioner. I paid $35 at the parts counter at my dealer for the "long" tensioner.
Pay particular attention to my posts in the following thread:
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...0-minis-6.html
(I am a Justa owner. See sig.)
DOC
#62
My post was not in response to your coolant loss issue (water pump?), but rather to your impending motor loss. Justas DO have catastrophic failures due to excessive timing chain slack. Due to various factors, it just takes more miles than on an N14. (All the same design/parts.) When you get over 72 mm, the OEM tensioner can no longer control the slack, teeth get skipped and no more autocrosses.
You can follow the Bentley manual instructions or Service Bulletin SI M11 02 07 to do it yourself, or have a dealer do it. It takes 30 min to check slack and replace the tensioner. I paid $35 at the parts counter at my dealer for the "long" tensioner.
Pay particular attention to my posts in the following thread:
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...0-minis-6.html
(I am a Justa owner. See sig.)
DOC
You can follow the Bentley manual instructions or Service Bulletin SI M11 02 07 to do it yourself, or have a dealer do it. It takes 30 min to check slack and replace the tensioner. I paid $35 at the parts counter at my dealer for the "long" tensioner.
Pay particular attention to my posts in the following thread:
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...0-minis-6.html
(I am a Justa owner. See sig.)
DOC
#64
Coolant Loss II - 4/19/2013
So I topped off in the chilly cold last night to here:
and here it is today (less than 1 mile driven, car not even cold):
Seems like I've got a problem?
Looks like the leak is on the passenger side: I've got some droplets on the lip as well as some on the plastic undertray beneath it. No event for me this weekend. Not sure at this point where the leak has been sprung
front facing back of the car:
back facing towards:
i let the car run a little, and oddly enough the expansion tank started filling, and no sign of increased dripping, anything.... thoughts?
and here it is today (less than 1 mile driven, car not even cold):
Seems like I've got a problem?
Looks like the leak is on the passenger side: I've got some droplets on the lip as well as some on the plastic undertray beneath it. No event for me this weekend. Not sure at this point where the leak has been sprung
front facing back of the car:
back facing towards:
i let the car run a little, and oddly enough the expansion tank started filling, and no sign of increased dripping, anything.... thoughts?
Last edited by kyoo; 04-19-2013 at 04:22 PM.
#65
Post Camber Mod Alignment - 4/19/2013
Aside from the coolant loss issues, I did get the car realigned - basically I asked for max camber in the front, minimum camber in the rear, and close to 0 toe all around. This is what I got:
Not too bad. Looks like the camber mod netted me about -0.2 degrees of camber from both sides - more or less what I expected. I was informed the car hit a really bad pothole on the pass side earlier in the life of the car - probably why the caster is off in the front right.
Unfortunately, I won't be able to use it, since I can't pinpoint where this coolant leak is coming from...
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3723237
Not too bad. Looks like the camber mod netted me about -0.2 degrees of camber from both sides - more or less what I expected. I was informed the car hit a really bad pothole on the pass side earlier in the life of the car - probably why the caster is off in the front right.
Unfortunately, I won't be able to use it, since I can't pinpoint where this coolant leak is coming from...
https://www.northamericanmotoring.co...ml#post3723237
Last edited by kyoo; 04-21-2013 at 07:04 PM.
#68
I've had very little need to pay for service at the dealer, the maintenance plan and warranty have taken care of most things. For things which wouldn't be covered I've found a good local independent BMW/MINI shop. Finding a good shop you can trust who have reasonable prices is a very good move.
#69
I've had very little need to pay for service at the dealer, the maintenance plan and warranty have taken care of most things. For things which wouldn't be covered I've found a good local independent BMW/MINI shop. Finding a good shop you can trust who have reasonable prices is a very good move.
#70
Air Filter Install - 4/20/2013
Very very simple install, but I'm trying to be committed in documenting everything I'm doing with the car:
K&N Filter PN #33-2386:
Tool needed for removing the air filter is a little atypical, but fortunately I had it. One tip - you only need to screw the screws out of the bottom part of the housing, and the screws will actually stay in the top portion - no need to worry about them falling out or anything. This is for an 08 base though, so may be different depending on the particular model. Afterwards, all you need to do is replace the top portion of the housing, align the screws, and you're all set.
I've got about five of these flashlights from Harbor Freight (like $3 each!) - it's got many LEDs on the face side, and a single led on the other side - also has a hook and a magnet on the back, and takes triple A batteries! Love these flashlights
Oddly, the K&N filter is much shorter than the OEM/Wix version but it fits:
Wiped down the housing:
New filter in!
Honestly, I couldn't tell a difference with it in, and actually completely forgot I installed it. Probably not any increase in HP - you'd probably only see a difference swapping the entire intake system out. Regardless, happy with the install etc.
K&N Filter PN #33-2386:
Tool needed for removing the air filter is a little atypical, but fortunately I had it. One tip - you only need to screw the screws out of the bottom part of the housing, and the screws will actually stay in the top portion - no need to worry about them falling out or anything. This is for an 08 base though, so may be different depending on the particular model. Afterwards, all you need to do is replace the top portion of the housing, align the screws, and you're all set.
I've got about five of these flashlights from Harbor Freight (like $3 each!) - it's got many LEDs on the face side, and a single led on the other side - also has a hook and a magnet on the back, and takes triple A batteries! Love these flashlights
Oddly, the K&N filter is much shorter than the OEM/Wix version but it fits:
Wiped down the housing:
New filter in!
Honestly, I couldn't tell a difference with it in, and actually completely forgot I installed it. Probably not any increase in HP - you'd probably only see a difference swapping the entire intake system out. Regardless, happy with the install etc.
Last edited by kyoo; 04-21-2013 at 06:58 PM.
#71
#72
5/5 Auto-x Preview
After a somewhat long hiatus, the Mini will enjoy it's next autocross event this weekend. This is an event that I've been looking forward to for a while, as an old friend of mine and I have made it the starting battleground for a long series of Civic vs Mini races.
However, I wanted to get your opinions on something: Sorry for the bench racing, but which car has the advantage for auto-x in this scenario? Everything on paper suggests the Civic (1997 Civic Hatchback) has the Mini covered -
We will be on the same tires, albeit mine will be 205s to his 185s. Brake pads will be similar. Similar driver level. I just don't see how I can make up for the weight penalty - thoughts?
Pros for 1997 Civic Hatch:
- 2,200 lbs
- Wider, lower, wider track
- Double wishbone front suspension
- Faster acceleration (tested) despite longer gear ratio (reaches 67mph in 2nd)
Cons:
- No ABS
- Slower steering rack
- Rear drum brakes
----------------------------------
Pros for the Mini Cooper base:
- Up to date suspension
- Shorter wheelbase (?)
- ABS
Cons:
- ~350lb!! weight penalty
- Taller
- Sunroof
However, I wanted to get your opinions on something: Sorry for the bench racing, but which car has the advantage for auto-x in this scenario? Everything on paper suggests the Civic (1997 Civic Hatchback) has the Mini covered -
We will be on the same tires, albeit mine will be 205s to his 185s. Brake pads will be similar. Similar driver level. I just don't see how I can make up for the weight penalty - thoughts?
Pros for 1997 Civic Hatch:
- 2,200 lbs
- Wider, lower, wider track
- Double wishbone front suspension
- Faster acceleration (tested) despite longer gear ratio (reaches 67mph in 2nd)
Cons:
- No ABS
- Slower steering rack
- Rear drum brakes
----------------------------------
Pros for the Mini Cooper base:
- Up to date suspension
- Shorter wheelbase (?)
- ABS
Cons:
- ~350lb!! weight penalty
- Taller
- Sunroof
#73
There's one way to find out.
Which model is it? The last Civic I drove was our old 93 DX. I thought that was a fine machine, until we got a MINI. Then the Civic seemed dangerous as it really didn't have the handling of the MINI. You'd do something the MINI would have no trouble with, only to find ourself overdriving the Civic and almost spinning out (on the street, not even autocross).
Which model is it? The last Civic I drove was our old 93 DX. I thought that was a fine machine, until we got a MINI. Then the Civic seemed dangerous as it really didn't have the handling of the MINI. You'd do something the MINI would have no trouble with, only to find ourself overdriving the Civic and almost spinning out (on the street, not even autocross).
#74
There's one way to find out.
Which model is it? The last Civic I drove was our old 93 DX. I thought that was a fine machine, until we got a MINI. Then the Civic seemed dangerous as it really didn't have the handling of the MINI. You'd do something the MINI would have no trouble with, only to find ourself overdriving the Civic and almost spinning out (on the street, not even autocross).
Which model is it? The last Civic I drove was our old 93 DX. I thought that was a fine machine, until we got a MINI. Then the Civic seemed dangerous as it really didn't have the handling of the MINI. You'd do something the MINI would have no trouble with, only to find ourself overdriving the Civic and almost spinning out (on the street, not even autocross).
#75
Is that weight verified? That seems a bit optimistic.
They weren't nearly as competitive as the EF chassis even when they were new. The R50s beat pretty much everything in the class when the came out and on most courses a R56 is faster than a R50.
Its probably a drivers race, it is HS after all. But I wouldn't underestimate that tire advantage either. 185s are like a bicycle tire.
They weren't nearly as competitive as the EF chassis even when they were new. The R50s beat pretty much everything in the class when the came out and on most courses a R56 is faster than a R50.
Its probably a drivers race, it is HS after all. But I wouldn't underestimate that tire advantage either. 185s are like a bicycle tire.