R56 To DSC or not - think think think
#27
#28
MR2 - Love that car - I had 2 1st gen N/A & SC 2nd gen N/A @ Turbo - loved the 2nd gen seats and turbo power
Thanks for all the feedback. I went to the dealer again tonight, but still having a hard time on the color. They had a pepper in the showroom - she was pretty! They still don't have on site for the SSilver. I'm just not sure not seeing it in real life. So I think I will go with my gut and stay with pepper.
So, I guess I can add DSC now, no prem paint to pay for.
hummm
Thanks for all the feedback. I went to the dealer again tonight, but still having a hard time on the color. They had a pepper in the showroom - she was pretty! They still don't have on site for the SSilver. I'm just not sure not seeing it in real life. So I think I will go with my gut and stay with pepper.
So, I guess I can add DSC now, no prem paint to pay for.
hummm
#29
I got the DSC and I think it is a nice safety feature and really pays off in the snow (even just getting moving). I turn it off when I do spirited driving and certainly when I am at the track.
Check out some other post of where people felt that the DSC actually reacted in a dangerous way. I've had it happen to me. You go to pull out into traffic (turning), the tires spin and the DSC kicks in way to much and there you sit with no power and cars bearing down on you In that situation, a human would be much better at manipulating the throttle to get going. Even with that, I'm glad I got it.
Check out some other post of where people felt that the DSC actually reacted in a dangerous way. I've had it happen to me. You go to pull out into traffic (turning), the tires spin and the DSC kicks in way to much and there you sit with no power and cars bearing down on you In that situation, a human would be much better at manipulating the throttle to get going. Even with that, I'm glad I got it.
#30
That sounds more like traction control than DSC. I think they all have traction control. DSC's action is primarily to prevent the car from getting sideways on you - it it detects the car beginning to yaw it applies brakes in the corner that will prevent the spin. Traction control on the other hand will control your acceleration to keep it within the available grip - no tire spinning on acceleration.
#33
Ok I'll weigh in
DSC came standard on our 2000 BMW Z3 and it will cut throttle when wheelspin is detected, including when negotiating a curve. When turned off, it will not.
DSC gives the car the ability to reduce throttle and/or apply individual brakes, but to my knowledge ASC+T can only apply brakes to individual drive (or non-drive) wheel to help control wheelspin. So the two appear to try to do the same thing in an opposing way.
The problem is that since OBDII, throttle response on BMW cars is *****, so when the car nannys your throttle when you're entering traffic, it can cause you to become a traffic hazard. Uneven pavement is usually what triggers ours. That and when I forgot to disable it on an autocross run, it ruined my run in the very first turn. Yes, it can cause you to stumble enough that it creates a perceptable stall in your forward motion.
For the record, we've decided against DSC for our Mini, but I imagine we'd consider it more seriously if we had to drive in snow and inclimate weather. Instead we've opted for the more predictable and perhaps more reliable LSD.
Karl (the dinosaur) In San Diego
DSC gives the car the ability to reduce throttle and/or apply individual brakes, but to my knowledge ASC+T can only apply brakes to individual drive (or non-drive) wheel to help control wheelspin. So the two appear to try to do the same thing in an opposing way.
The problem is that since OBDII, throttle response on BMW cars is *****, so when the car nannys your throttle when you're entering traffic, it can cause you to become a traffic hazard. Uneven pavement is usually what triggers ours. That and when I forgot to disable it on an autocross run, it ruined my run in the very first turn. Yes, it can cause you to stumble enough that it creates a perceptable stall in your forward motion.
For the record, we've decided against DSC for our Mini, but I imagine we'd consider it more seriously if we had to drive in snow and inclimate weather. Instead we've opted for the more predictable and perhaps more reliable LSD.
Karl (the dinosaur) In San Diego
#34
Not getting DSC...
is like not getting insurance and hoping you save $ over time.... Maybe you will, maybe you don't.
From the highway folks. DSC will be mandated for all cars and light trucks (don't know about real trucks) by 2012. They expect that about 30%+ of roll-over accidents will be avoided with DSC, and over half! for SUVs and higher center of mass vehicles. These projections are based on data mining from recent accident data.
I'm not going to get any friends with this one, but you turn it off on the streets, you are not a smart person. I can see turning it off at a problem place (driveway that always has a puddle or something) but to turn it off on the streets for some "hot" driving in the hills or whatever is just dumb. Sure, many haven't driven with it for most of thier lives, but saying that the past defines the standard for wisdom, technology, or safety equipment is nieve at best. But to drive on public streets without the system if it's on your car is increasing the risk to you, your passengers, and those on the road near you.
If the one thing that bothers you with the DSC/ASC systems is you can't hammer it out of a driveway, either learn to feather the throttel (like any one who has drivin a high HP car has) or spend the money for the ECU tunes that make it less intrusive.
Matt
From the highway folks. DSC will be mandated for all cars and light trucks (don't know about real trucks) by 2012. They expect that about 30%+ of roll-over accidents will be avoided with DSC, and over half! for SUVs and higher center of mass vehicles. These projections are based on data mining from recent accident data.
I'm not going to get any friends with this one, but you turn it off on the streets, you are not a smart person. I can see turning it off at a problem place (driveway that always has a puddle or something) but to turn it off on the streets for some "hot" driving in the hills or whatever is just dumb. Sure, many haven't driven with it for most of thier lives, but saying that the past defines the standard for wisdom, technology, or safety equipment is nieve at best. But to drive on public streets without the system if it's on your car is increasing the risk to you, your passengers, and those on the road near you.
If the one thing that bothers you with the DSC/ASC systems is you can't hammer it out of a driveway, either learn to feather the throttel (like any one who has drivin a high HP car has) or spend the money for the ECU tunes that make it less intrusive.
Matt
#35
OK who knows if the leather/cloth combo comes in black? The Germany version has it, but miniusa only lists red and blue as the cloth and leather combo options. It looks real good on the mello yellow I saw last night.
Thats my last change to call it a day. If its not avail then I'm forced to pay 1500 for the other black leather. I'm already 3k over budget, but keep telling myself its for the long term. And when I got my ridgeline there were a few things, looking back, that I wished I had added to it vs the lot pic!
Interior choices:
Chrome Line Interior Trim
Piano Black Interior Surfaces
Anthracite Interior Headliner
Dark Grey Color Line
And leahter once I figure this out! or worse case Punch Carbon
Prem Pkg
Sport Pkg
Heated Seats
17 Bridge Spoke
White Turn Sig
Rear Fog
Hi-Fi
Black Bonnet Stripes
Pwr fold mirrors
Auto Headlight / Washers
Blk roof and caps
Thanks again!!! OH, I'm staying with pepper - at least now I don't have to change my call sign
A note on not getting cold pkg. If you get the cold package you can't get folding heated mirrors - crazzzy
AND I'm such a rock - my ridgeline has DSC - its standard. I remember it kicking in a few times under a punch and go and it held back a bit. when someone made that comment I clicked in my small mind. duh
Thats my last change to call it a day. If its not avail then I'm forced to pay 1500 for the other black leather. I'm already 3k over budget, but keep telling myself its for the long term. And when I got my ridgeline there were a few things, looking back, that I wished I had added to it vs the lot pic!
Interior choices:
Chrome Line Interior Trim
Piano Black Interior Surfaces
Anthracite Interior Headliner
Dark Grey Color Line
And leahter once I figure this out! or worse case Punch Carbon
Prem Pkg
Sport Pkg
Heated Seats
17 Bridge Spoke
White Turn Sig
Rear Fog
Hi-Fi
Black Bonnet Stripes
Pwr fold mirrors
Auto Headlight / Washers
Blk roof and caps
Thanks again!!! OH, I'm staying with pepper - at least now I don't have to change my call sign
A note on not getting cold pkg. If you get the cold package you can't get folding heated mirrors - crazzzy
AND I'm such a rock - my ridgeline has DSC - its standard. I remember it kicking in a few times under a punch and go and it held back a bit. when someone made that comment I clicked in my small mind. duh
#37
#39
While doing a little "fun" driving on my favorite low-traffic twisty road a couple of days ago, I went into a corner a little hotter than usual- turned out to be a little TOO hot. And on this particular run, for the first time ever, I met a BIG PICKUP TRUCK coming the other way around said corner. I was on the inside. He was on the outside. DSC saved my MINI and his pickup. It kept me in control and in my lane as it slowed me around the corner. This was on dry pavement.
I am a TRUE BELIEVER in DSC. ESPECIALLY in a car like the MCS.
I am a TRUE BELIEVER in DSC. ESPECIALLY in a car like the MCS.
#40
DSC came standard on our 2000 BMW Z3 and it will cut throttle when wheelspin is detected, including when negotiating a curve. When turned off, it will not.
DSC gives the car the ability to reduce throttle and/or apply individual brakes, but to my knowledge ASC+T can only apply brakes to individual drive (or non-drive) wheel to help control wheelspin. So the two appear to try to do the same thing in an opposing way.
The problem is that since OBDII, throttle response on BMW cars is *****, so when the car nannys your throttle when you're entering traffic, it can cause you to become a traffic hazard. Uneven pavement is usually what triggers ours. That and when I forgot to disable it on an autocross run, it ruined my run in the very first turn. Yes, it can cause you to stumble enough that it creates a perceptable stall in your forward motion.
For the record, we've decided against DSC for our Mini, but I imagine we'd consider it more seriously if we had to drive in snow and inclimate weather. Instead we've opted for the more predictable and perhaps more reliable LSD.
Karl (the dinosaur) In San Diego
DSC gives the car the ability to reduce throttle and/or apply individual brakes, but to my knowledge ASC+T can only apply brakes to individual drive (or non-drive) wheel to help control wheelspin. So the two appear to try to do the same thing in an opposing way.
The problem is that since OBDII, throttle response on BMW cars is *****, so when the car nannys your throttle when you're entering traffic, it can cause you to become a traffic hazard. Uneven pavement is usually what triggers ours. That and when I forgot to disable it on an autocross run, it ruined my run in the very first turn. Yes, it can cause you to stumble enough that it creates a perceptable stall in your forward motion.
For the record, we've decided against DSC for our Mini, but I imagine we'd consider it more seriously if we had to drive in snow and inclimate weather. Instead we've opted for the more predictable and perhaps more reliable LSD.
Karl (the dinosaur) In San Diego
#41
Agree about seeing the SS in person. Looks great in the sun. Disagree about the black top. I think it looks wonderful with white roof and stripes.
#42
I hope they are better. My '02 Z3's DSC was soooo sensitive that I could not keep up with other cars on the 270 degree freeway interchange. The car went "jerk-jerk-jerk-jerk-jerk...." all the way around ON DRY PAVEMENT. It sucked. I turned it off every time I approached a high speed turn. I guess I will be ordering the DSC with my r56. 106 days to go.
#43
Is this really even debatable? Saying you don't like DSC because it interfers with your driving is like my former step father saying he didn't like to wear his seatbelt because it was uncomfortable. Or better yet, saying you hate ABS because it won't let you make that cool screeching noise when you slam on the brakes. DSC should be standard and for those that like to be weekend warrior race car drivers... just turn it off. I'll just be sure not to be driving behind you.
#44
Is this really even debatable? Saying you don't like DSC because it interfers with your driving is like my former step father saying he didn't like to wear his seatbelt because it was uncomfortable. Or better yet, saying you hate ABS because it won't let you make that cool screeching noise when you slam on the brakes. DSC should be standard and for those that like to be weekend warrior race car drivers... just turn it off. I'll just be sure not to be driving behind you.
Last edited by r56mini; 04-13-2007 at 03:56 PM.
#45
Is this really even debatable? Saying you don't like DSC because it interfers with your driving is like my former step father saying he didn't like to wear his seatbelt because it was uncomfortable. Or better yet, saying you hate ABS because it won't let you make that cool screeching noise when you slam on the brakes. DSC should be standard and for those that like to be weekend warrior race car drivers... just turn it off. I'll just be sure not to be driving behind you.
#46
#47
Sparkling Silver is a very interesting color that almost changes moods under varying light. Under a gray sky, it almost appears have a light green-gold hue at times. In direct sunlight, champagne most definitely. And looking in the rear view mirror down the sides, I think I am actually seeing silver!
No matter, Sparkling Silver is one beautiful color. I have received TONS of great comments around town about the color so far...& combined w/ black leather seats and piano black/english oak/chrome trim...it's a class act that puts the MINI way over the toy car status! It's downright POSH!
Cheers!
No matter, Sparkling Silver is one beautiful color. I have received TONS of great comments around town about the color so far...& combined w/ black leather seats and piano black/english oak/chrome trim...it's a class act that puts the MINI way over the toy car status! It's downright POSH!
Cheers!
#48
When I order my R56. May be a year or two, but I will. Two things won't be on my car, leather & DSC. To me the leather is a whole lot of money for what you get. I like to drive my car, so no DSC for me. I do not want the car to drive me. With the money saved on those 2 items one could go to quite a few drivers schools & learn how to drive. Just my 2 cents, do what you feel you need to. No electro nannies for me.
PS: I hope Ian Cull makes a circuit to turn off the traction control. I have one on my R53 & its my favorite mod.
Sparkling sliver looks like a color my Dad would have on his Buick. Too my eye it's not a MINI color. Just my 2 cents again.
PS: I hope Ian Cull makes a circuit to turn off the traction control. I have one on my R53 & its my favorite mod.
Sparkling sliver looks like a color my Dad would have on his Buick. Too my eye it's not a MINI color. Just my 2 cents again.
#49
#50
Obviously, you never had a car with over-working DSC. ... blah, blah, blah,.... Wouldn't you complain if you had a rain sensing wipers that went on whenever the car in front of you sprayed windshield washer?