Giac/mth/unichip
#1
Giac/mth/unichip
The above (3) Products.... are simply in alphabetical order.... to show no favoritism
I owned an 02 MCS... w/ a 15% Helix pulley/Madness Intake/last one on was a Borla Street Exhaust ( for those who know me ) and the Webb Motorsport Powerchip software.
It was a fun car... ran extremely well...
Sold it in 04.
(Had a MCoupe for 1&1/2 years....actually sold it last nite :(...but... now I'm back in the MINI ... fold )
I now own a 06 MCS w/ 500 miles on it...
It is currently equipted with:
A Helix 19% pulley/Helix Intake/ yup... a Borla Street Exhaust & by close of business tomorrow... JCW Injectors
(Got a Helix short shifter/ HSport springs & rear sway bar/Kosei K1TS rims/ Goodyear F1GSD3 tires/Whalen shifter....and other stuff... just to embelish a bit )
Here's why I invited you all here...
SOFTWARE/HARDWARE SOLUTION?????????????????
That's the last piece o da puzzle.. (kinda,sorta...maybe...lol)
I've spent about (2) weeks....
-reading....reading....reading...then reading some more... then re-reading... again & again... (get the picture) re: above software choices.
-pm'ing friends/strangers (people are still extremly nice here... just an observation).... to pick thier brains
-numerous tel calls to Eric (Helix)
-numerous tel calls to Randy (WebbMotorsports)
-numerous tel calls to Barry (local NY rep for MTH)
-numerous tel calls to Eric from (RPM Racing)
-many emails to the three tuner/software companies...GIAC/MTH/UNICHIP
***All three companies... (GIAC/MTH/UNICHIP) may I add... have not had the courtesy to reply... to date*** (that would be another rant....)
I drive in a spirited manner...
Track the car once or twice per year...
Autocross.... about the same.
I'm a MINI MA so I don't get out in the real world much anymore...rofl...except f/ test drives ..which can be a dangerous... experience.
I'm teathered to the dealership...
It's ... a life choice... or lack ...thereof
I'm totally stumped as to which of the above solutions make sence...
to go forward with.
The floor is open... please come forth... and ... express your opinions...
I am listening
Peace,
D
I owned an 02 MCS... w/ a 15% Helix pulley/Madness Intake/last one on was a Borla Street Exhaust ( for those who know me ) and the Webb Motorsport Powerchip software.
It was a fun car... ran extremely well...
Sold it in 04.
(Had a MCoupe for 1&1/2 years....actually sold it last nite :(...but... now I'm back in the MINI ... fold )
I now own a 06 MCS w/ 500 miles on it...
It is currently equipted with:
A Helix 19% pulley/Helix Intake/ yup... a Borla Street Exhaust & by close of business tomorrow... JCW Injectors
(Got a Helix short shifter/ HSport springs & rear sway bar/Kosei K1TS rims/ Goodyear F1GSD3 tires/Whalen shifter....and other stuff... just to embelish a bit )
Here's why I invited you all here...
SOFTWARE/HARDWARE SOLUTION?????????????????
That's the last piece o da puzzle.. (kinda,sorta...maybe...lol)
I've spent about (2) weeks....
-reading....reading....reading...then reading some more... then re-reading... again & again... (get the picture) re: above software choices.
-pm'ing friends/strangers (people are still extremly nice here... just an observation).... to pick thier brains
-numerous tel calls to Eric (Helix)
-numerous tel calls to Randy (WebbMotorsports)
-numerous tel calls to Barry (local NY rep for MTH)
-numerous tel calls to Eric from (RPM Racing)
-many emails to the three tuner/software companies...GIAC/MTH/UNICHIP
***All three companies... (GIAC/MTH/UNICHIP) may I add... have not had the courtesy to reply... to date*** (that would be another rant....)
I drive in a spirited manner...
Track the car once or twice per year...
Autocross.... about the same.
I'm a MINI MA so I don't get out in the real world much anymore...rofl...except f/ test drives ..which can be a dangerous... experience.
I'm teathered to the dealership...
It's ... a life choice... or lack ...thereof
I'm totally stumped as to which of the above solutions make sence...
to go forward with.
The floor is open... please come forth... and ... express your opinions...
I am listening
Peace,
D
#2
well here's my tuppence worth,
I have MTH and the reason I chose it is because it is easily installed,
easily put back to stock if you so wish,
if your dealer flashes your car you simply request a new file from MTH and your'e back cooking again,
it totally transforms the car as do all the above but if you add something extra or change something you simply request a new file,
no need to remove your ecu and send it off,
and its probably the cheapest and best value for money you can get,
I have MTH and the reason I chose it is because it is easily installed,
easily put back to stock if you so wish,
if your dealer flashes your car you simply request a new file from MTH and your'e back cooking again,
it totally transforms the car as do all the above but if you add something extra or change something you simply request a new file,
no need to remove your ecu and send it off,
and its probably the cheapest and best value for money you can get,
#3
Long time MTH user.....
For what you've got on your car, it will be fine. Having the abilitiy to upload/download at will is nice too.
If I were to do it all over again? I honestly don't know. Dinan stuff seems nice, but then it ain't cheap!
Andy seriously dislikes the UniChip, and to really make it scream, you should have it custom tuned, and you need to go to a UniChip tuner to do that... More $$$$
I've been curious about the Apex'i S-AFC. There was one in Marketplace for $200, but you need to tune it for your car as well.
I think you'll find that there are many who are very happy with the choice that they made, and see no need to get another solution to do a comparison.
Kind of sucks, but there you have it.
Matt
If I were to do it all over again? I honestly don't know. Dinan stuff seems nice, but then it ain't cheap!
Andy seriously dislikes the UniChip, and to really make it scream, you should have it custom tuned, and you need to go to a UniChip tuner to do that... More $$$$
I've been curious about the Apex'i S-AFC. There was one in Marketplace for $200, but you need to tune it for your car as well.
I think you'll find that there are many who are very happy with the choice that they made, and see no need to get another solution to do a comparison.
Kind of sucks, but there you have it.
Matt
#5
I've used MTH and GIAC. Started with MTH, primarily as he could tweak the e-throttle to keep the rpm from holding so much when the clutch is put in. The change in that aspect was very obvious, and worked great. Power seemed slightly better, but no huge difference. The ASC mod was also subtle but nice. I had no fault codes, and the engine started and ran fine.
I used MTH with a stock diameter pulley as well as 19%, with and without JCW inectors. All statements above apply to both.
After a couple successful calibration loads and swaps, I had trouble one night and the ECM locked up completely. Same laptop, same cable, samer operator (me).
I sent the ECM to Eric at Helix and he was able to get the GIAC (for 19% and injectors) to load alright. Once again, a huge Thank you! to Helix for taking on this challenge, getting it turned around very quickly, and saving me a (probably very expensive) visit to the dealership.
I've been very satisfied with the GIAC calibration too. The engine is back to its old (OEM) trick of hanging onto revs during shifts, but it runs flawlessly and also has not thrown any codes. The GIAC seems to keep pulling in the last 1000rpm better than before, but differences are not earthshattering.
Scott
90SM
I used MTH with a stock diameter pulley as well as 19%, with and without JCW inectors. All statements above apply to both.
After a couple successful calibration loads and swaps, I had trouble one night and the ECM locked up completely. Same laptop, same cable, samer operator (me).
I sent the ECM to Eric at Helix and he was able to get the GIAC (for 19% and injectors) to load alright. Once again, a huge Thank you! to Helix for taking on this challenge, getting it turned around very quickly, and saving me a (probably very expensive) visit to the dealership.
I've been very satisfied with the GIAC calibration too. The engine is back to its old (OEM) trick of hanging onto revs during shifts, but it runs flawlessly and also has not thrown any codes. The GIAC seems to keep pulling in the last 1000rpm better than before, but differences are not earthshattering.
Scott
90SM
#7
6th Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 3,291
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You and I are at the exact same place which ECU Upgrade is the correct one for us. There are so many variables besides the "end result ":
Cost
Installation
dealership reflash
warranty concerns
I'm sure there's more ... drawn a blank.
You need to prioritize these potential issues/concerns - once you do that, the right one will appear.
As an example - originally I was going to do GIAC because at the time I had basic mods - pulley/cai/exhaust which GIAC addresses and ease of installation was a high priority (i.e. I pay, they install/ I drive off). So off I went - to keep it short the distributor could NOT install the upgrade after I drove over an hour to get there. This made me rethink the situation and while I was rethinking, I added more mods which GIAC doesn't address but MTH does. So if I want to address the additional mods, I had to change the importance of installation.
Cost
Installation
dealership reflash
warranty concerns
I'm sure there's more ... drawn a blank.
You need to prioritize these potential issues/concerns - once you do that, the right one will appear.
As an example - originally I was going to do GIAC because at the time I had basic mods - pulley/cai/exhaust which GIAC addresses and ease of installation was a high priority (i.e. I pay, they install/ I drive off). So off I went - to keep it short the distributor could NOT install the upgrade after I drove over an hour to get there. This made me rethink the situation and while I was rethinking, I added more mods which GIAC doesn't address but MTH does. So if I want to address the additional mods, I had to change the importance of installation.
Trending Topics
#12
Not at all...
Originally Posted by 1FSTMINI
If im reading this right.....Are you sayin the Tuner map doesnt adjust the DSC or redline b.c mine is adjusted from what they told me. I barely hit redline when im racing because it feels stronger if i shift earlier than 7k
No statement here that you couldn't bundle whatever you want out of the never listed options that MTH can do. But like the UniChip can't change the red-line settings.... It would just be a way to use UniChip, and get higher revs....
Matt
ps, this is definantly one of my frustrations with MTH, I can't find a list anywhere of what you can and cannot get modified. At one time Franz said that they could get the ECU to support a wideband, and then Volker says no. There have been posts about alternator, fan AC etc etc etc.
I would really love it if the upload page had checkboxes for what mods you have, checkboxes for what you want changed, maybe drop down lists of options etc, and a place to upload A/F plots from dyno runs. I think it would make MTH's life easier, and it would sure clear up some ambiguity for us customers....
#14
#15
Originally Posted by Dr Obnxs
I was just wondering if someone who wanted to use another tuning option has ever tried to use MTH for some of the non-power issues, like DSC, rev fall during shift and red-line modification BY CHOICE, and then used a different product for the power.....
No statement here that you couldn't bundle whatever you want out of the never listed options that MTH can do. But like the UniChip can't change the red-line settings.... It would just be a way to use UniChip, and get higher revs....
Matt
No statement here that you couldn't bundle whatever you want out of the never listed options that MTH can do. But like the UniChip can't change the red-line settings.... It would just be a way to use UniChip, and get higher revs....
Matt
I agree that a custom dyno tune would be the best situation, but with a flash, not a piggyback.
As for d-mini-ero's dilemma, I can't really offer any additional guidance other than to go see Eric to give the GIAC a try. Just watch out for the "for a few dollars more" special offers:
#16
Decision
Morales sent me a set of serial cables to download my ECU info.
Dkstone sent me the necc software.... &.... friendly support
I dragged one of my 11 desktop puters into the garage (as my laptop doesn't have a serial port)... and did the deed.
Sent the file(s) of to MTH...
Patiently awtg the "Tuner" file.
My only concern is a 10 day wait for the MTH file to return.
Got an email from GIAC... they don't seem to have a 06 file available yet. They are working on it...no time frame given.
The Unichp seems too pricey and does n't have the ability to change variables (ie...rev limiter) ..that is personally important to me
My decison basically came down to ...ease of use.
I can flash my own car..whenever I choose.
I have several GOOD freinds local who use the software..for support.
I'm assuming (time will tell if this was a good choice)... the differences in all the above software remaps... are minor.
Peace,
D
Dkstone sent me the necc software.... &.... friendly support
I dragged one of my 11 desktop puters into the garage (as my laptop doesn't have a serial port)... and did the deed.
Sent the file(s) of to MTH...
Patiently awtg the "Tuner" file.
My only concern is a 10 day wait for the MTH file to return.
Got an email from GIAC... they don't seem to have a 06 file available yet. They are working on it...no time frame given.
The Unichp seems too pricey and does n't have the ability to change variables (ie...rev limiter) ..that is personally important to me
My decison basically came down to ...ease of use.
I can flash my own car..whenever I choose.
I have several GOOD freinds local who use the software..for support.
I'm assuming (time will tell if this was a good choice)... the differences in all the above software remaps... are minor.
Peace,
D
#17
6th Gear
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Hotlanta
Posts: 2,645
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dennis,
Not for nothing but you asked me to order you injectors, you then called back an canceled.
You asked me to install them...Then you called me back to cancel that
You asked me to do the MTH flash...and now im seeing you dont need me for that either.
Im not trying to be a d*ck....But i have better things to do than make appointmens and order parts for people just tryin to get info out of me to have you cancel it all. :impatient
Not for nothing but you asked me to order you injectors, you then called back an canceled.
You asked me to install them...Then you called me back to cancel that
You asked me to do the MTH flash...and now im seeing you dont need me for that either.
Im not trying to be a d*ck....But i have better things to do than make appointmens and order parts for people just tryin to get info out of me to have you cancel it all. :impatient
#18
Originally Posted by andy@ross-tech.com
Adding a piggyback on top of a flash should definitley be feasible since the piggyback merely alters the MAP sensor signal. I would definitely not want to put a pre-programmed piggyback (like the Unichip that Randy sells) on top of a chipped ECU like MTH or GIAC. You could end up with a situation where the base map was leaner than stock, then the piggyback tried to make it leaner still.
I agree that a custom dyno tune would be the best situation, but with a flash, not a piggyback.
As for d-mini-ero's dilemma, I can't really offer any additional guidance other than to go see Eric to give the GIAC a try. Just watch out for the "for a few dollars more" special offers:
I agree that a custom dyno tune would be the best situation, but with a flash, not a piggyback.
As for d-mini-ero's dilemma, I can't really offer any additional guidance other than to go see Eric to give the GIAC a try. Just watch out for the "for a few dollars more" special offers:
I have been in some MTH cars that performed very well.... GIAC certainly has the pedigree
#19
1FSTMINI,
I'm sorry if I offended you.
I asked you and many other people as listed in the above to look into this software/hardware choice.
I purchased the injectors at a lower price.
I got the injectors installed for a lower price.
I ordered the software at the same price... & will have possession of the file(s).
I am a consumer.... and.... a sales professional.
I am a MINI MA ( as you know) & people come to visit me every day to get info from me... & then they decide whether or not to use my services.
I shop (like all customers do) to get the best price and most convenient delivery.
Again... I'm truly sorry if this offended you.
Peace,
D
I'm sorry if I offended you.
I asked you and many other people as listed in the above to look into this software/hardware choice.
I purchased the injectors at a lower price.
I got the injectors installed for a lower price.
I ordered the software at the same price... & will have possession of the file(s).
I am a consumer.... and.... a sales professional.
I am a MINI MA ( as you know) & people come to visit me every day to get info from me... & then they decide whether or not to use my services.
I shop (like all customers do) to get the best price and most convenient delivery.
Again... I'm truly sorry if this offended you.
Peace,
D
Originally Posted by 1FSTMINI
Dennis,
Not for nothing but you asked me to order you injectors, you then called back an canceled.
You asked me to install them...Then you called me back to cancel that
You asked me to do the MTH flash...and now im seeing you dont need me for that either.
Im not trying to be a d*ck....But i have better things to do than make appointmens and order parts for people just tryin to get info out of me to have you cancel it all. :impatient
Not for nothing but you asked me to order you injectors, you then called back an canceled.
You asked me to install them...Then you called me back to cancel that
You asked me to do the MTH flash...and now im seeing you dont need me for that either.
Im not trying to be a d*ck....But i have better things to do than make appointmens and order parts for people just tryin to get info out of me to have you cancel it all. :impatient
#20
I ordered the MTH Tuner File & cable yesterday. I plan on doing several things with the service. When I get the file I'll get a stock file and tuned file dyno run done. At the end of Feb I'm having CAI & 17% pulley installed. I'll dyno that with stock file, tuned stock file & tuned for mods file. I'll report with a % changes table early March.
I'm going with MTH for ease of install.
I'm going with MTH for ease of install.
#21
Im not positive what my unichip made over stock (the program it came with), but once I got it tuned I made an additional 8-12 WHP. The exact number Im not sure of because between the two comparisions (program that cam preloaded vs custom tuned) I also had an AGS and throttle body installed. In the end I pulled about 12 WHP more than I did with the Alta, stock TB, and pre-programmed unichip.
#22
#23
#24
I say go with neither and get an AFC select. i had the GIAC software with a 17% pulley, JCW injectors, K&N CAI, Custom 3" exhaust had it dynoed at 168@ the wheels. Then a buddy of mine pulled the software out, played around with the stock software and tuned it with the AFC, then got my car redynoed and now i'm pushing 185@ the wheels. just my .02, good luck on your choice
#25
1st impressions
Drove it. ...
I'll drive it more this comming weekend ... as sunday they'll actually let me outa the MINI showroom
1st impressions....
-smoother thru the gears.... no flat spots that I noticed.
-butt-dyno...I felt power increases accross all gears.
JMHO...it's kinda the glue that brings all the mods together and allows them to play nice and get along w/ each other.
Seems to be money well spent...
Thanks for listening...
Peace,
D
I'll drive it more this comming weekend ... as sunday they'll actually let me outa the MINI showroom
1st impressions....
-smoother thru the gears.... no flat spots that I noticed.
-butt-dyno...I felt power increases accross all gears.
JMHO...it's kinda the glue that brings all the mods together and allows them to play nice and get along w/ each other.
Seems to be money well spent...
Thanks for listening...
Peace,
D