Suspension Can someone explain suspension components?
#1
#2
6th Gear
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Ohio
Posts: 3,952
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This will give you a pretty in depth run through of the suspension along with how, why's and tradeoffs.
http://auto.howstuffworks.com/car-suspension.htm
http://auto.howstuffworks.com/car-suspension.htm
#3
#4
#6
#7
3rd Gear
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 271
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok, maybe I'm just stuck on stupid, but I don't quite get it.
I've read the howstuffworks writeup (very informative), and from the pictures, it looks as if a Strut and a Coilover are the same thing, minus the adjustability of the coilover. Their pictures of a strut show a spring around the outside of the unit, like a coilover. Ok, fine. But when I go to try to purchase a Strut they look exactly the same as a shock. As one example, on MINI Madness' page (http://www.mini-madness.com/index.as...S&Category=209) the FSD struts and the Yellow shocks look identical for the front components. I understand there are differences between fronts and backs, so I'm just talking about front FSD's verses front Yellows.
I guess basically I have three questions:
1. Shouldn't a "strut" have a spring on the outside as part of the unit to be called a strut? Otherwise its just a shock, right?
2. Can I keep my lowering springs if I buy struts or do they come with their own that can't be replaced?
3. Or is all of this just one hell of a misnomer and there's really no difference until the actual part is combined with the existing spring like Voltron and put in the car?
Ugh...All this to figure out why I've got one hell of a right pull on my car and I'm blowing through my right tires. Thanks in advance for help clearing this up.
I've read the howstuffworks writeup (very informative), and from the pictures, it looks as if a Strut and a Coilover are the same thing, minus the adjustability of the coilover. Their pictures of a strut show a spring around the outside of the unit, like a coilover. Ok, fine. But when I go to try to purchase a Strut they look exactly the same as a shock. As one example, on MINI Madness' page (http://www.mini-madness.com/index.as...S&Category=209) the FSD struts and the Yellow shocks look identical for the front components. I understand there are differences between fronts and backs, so I'm just talking about front FSD's verses front Yellows.
I guess basically I have three questions:
1. Shouldn't a "strut" have a spring on the outside as part of the unit to be called a strut? Otherwise its just a shock, right?
2. Can I keep my lowering springs if I buy struts or do they come with their own that can't be replaced?
3. Or is all of this just one hell of a misnomer and there's really no difference until the actual part is combined with the existing spring like Voltron and put in the car?
Ugh...All this to figure out why I've got one hell of a right pull on my car and I'm blowing through my right tires. Thanks in advance for help clearing this up.
Trending Topics
#8
Wow... you ARE pretty confused.
I guess basically I have three questions:
1. Shouldn't a "strut" have a spring on the outside as part of the unit to be called a strut? Otherwise its just a shock, right?
You'll find lots of conflicting definitions regarding the difference between a strut and a shock. One that I've heard is that a "strut" is a structural, load bearing component of the suspension - on the front of the MINI, if you remove the front strut, the steering knuckle flops over - the wheel won't stay upright without the strut. The strut actually carries a significant portion of the car's side load when cornering. A "shock" solely acts as a damper, not a structural component - which is true on the rear of the MINI. But, in another sense, some folks consider both to be "struts" because they work in conjunction with a coil spring mounted on the body of the strut itself (as you suggest). Clear as mud, eh? But it's a strut because is uses a spring around it to function - it doesn't only get to be called a strut after the spring is installed. The spring is not "part" of the strut. Short version - if you buy something call either struts or shocks or coilovers for a MINI - they are functionally the same things (except for the adjustability of the coilover).
2. Can I keep my lowering springs if I buy struts or do they come with their own that can't be replaced?
Struts typically do NOT come with springs installed. Coilovers typically DO come with springs installed. But there are exceptions. But, for the examples you list, Koni FSDs and Yellows do NOT come with springs. You use the OEM springs, or add aftermarket springs.
3. Or is all of this just one hell of a misnomer and there's really no difference until the actual part is combined with the existing spring like Voltron and put in the car?
See answer to #1. Shock/strut + spring (plus spring perches, plus maybe camber plates in front) = something that you install to actually do something. None of the components work individually without the others.
I guess basically I have three questions:
1. Shouldn't a "strut" have a spring on the outside as part of the unit to be called a strut? Otherwise its just a shock, right?
You'll find lots of conflicting definitions regarding the difference between a strut and a shock. One that I've heard is that a "strut" is a structural, load bearing component of the suspension - on the front of the MINI, if you remove the front strut, the steering knuckle flops over - the wheel won't stay upright without the strut. The strut actually carries a significant portion of the car's side load when cornering. A "shock" solely acts as a damper, not a structural component - which is true on the rear of the MINI. But, in another sense, some folks consider both to be "struts" because they work in conjunction with a coil spring mounted on the body of the strut itself (as you suggest). Clear as mud, eh? But it's a strut because is uses a spring around it to function - it doesn't only get to be called a strut after the spring is installed. The spring is not "part" of the strut. Short version - if you buy something call either struts or shocks or coilovers for a MINI - they are functionally the same things (except for the adjustability of the coilover).
2. Can I keep my lowering springs if I buy struts or do they come with their own that can't be replaced?
Struts typically do NOT come with springs installed. Coilovers typically DO come with springs installed. But there are exceptions. But, for the examples you list, Koni FSDs and Yellows do NOT come with springs. You use the OEM springs, or add aftermarket springs.
3. Or is all of this just one hell of a misnomer and there's really no difference until the actual part is combined with the existing spring like Voltron and put in the car?
See answer to #1. Shock/strut + spring (plus spring perches, plus maybe camber plates in front) = something that you install to actually do something. None of the components work individually without the others.
#10
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Navigation & Audio HK Replacement With New Components
Filmy
Navigation & Audio
15
06-06-2023 06:27 AM
ej
MINI Parts for Sale
5
11-17-2015 09:21 PM