Compact spare voids warranty??
#1
Compact spare voids warranty??
Stopped by my dealer today to order a compact spare from a Cooper for my week-old S. The parts dept. was having a problem finding the correct part # and called Mini parts tech support. They were told that the compact spare "was not recommended" for the "S". Furthermore, if they sold me one the invoice needed to state that in the case of any suspension, ABS, DSC, etc. problems, the warranty was void!! My helpful (and disbelieving) sales rep is going to contact his technical sources, but in the meantime have any of you guys run into this? I've read that the compact spares from a Civic and maybe an Acura will fit, but I really don't have the time to research it and just wanted to get set p for my non run-flat winter tires. (Do THEY void my warranty too?) Suppose I use gas not supplied by my dealer and have a fuel injuction problem? Not covered? Sorry, getting sarcastic here. I just hate this sort of c__p. Thanks.
#2
#3
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Burning-Ham Alabama
Posts: 10,170
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
That sounds like something you would hear at Global Imports in Atlanta. . .
They are the ones that tried to tell me that driving through the mountains on a single weekend trip had voided my warranty on unmodified unaltered stock OEM brakes!
You can save 20% and not have your dealer follow through on their idiotic warranty voiding threats by calling Classic MINI in Ohio (a vendor sponsor of this site) and having them send you one. . . .
They are the ones that tried to tell me that driving through the mountains on a single weekend trip had voided my warranty on unmodified unaltered stock OEM brakes!
You can save 20% and not have your dealer follow through on their idiotic warranty voiding threats by calling Classic MINI in Ohio (a vendor sponsor of this site) and having them send you one. . . .
#4
I think they would have a hard time enforcing that since the
MINI and the MCS have the same suspension and brakes
(assuming no Sport Suspension Plus, but what they were
telling you sounds like a "blanket statement" meaning they
would try to apply it to everyone regardless of whether their
car has SS+ or not) and they happily supply and advocate
the use of that same spare on it. The only thing you have to
worry about with a compact spare is that it must never be
used on the front end of a car with LSD, which could tear up
the diff.
I would ask to speak to the zone rep or call MINIUSA.
MINI and the MCS have the same suspension and brakes
(assuming no Sport Suspension Plus, but what they were
telling you sounds like a "blanket statement" meaning they
would try to apply it to everyone regardless of whether their
car has SS+ or not) and they happily supply and advocate
the use of that same spare on it. The only thing you have to
worry about with a compact spare is that it must never be
used on the front end of a car with LSD, which could tear up
the diff.
I would ask to speak to the zone rep or call MINIUSA.
#7
Trending Topics
#8
Its not the speed that you drive that causes a problem with mounting a donut spare on the drive wheels its the difference in circumference (distance around the outer edge of the tire) Because the donut is so much smaller it causes a significant difference in the rotational speed of the wheels on each side. If this is happening on a drive wheel, this causes the differential (LSD or otherwise) to constantly compensate just as if you were driving in a continuous circle instead of in a straight line. Given time that can lead to premature wearing of the differential components and failure. The same is true for putting a donut on the back of a rear wheel drive or ANY corner of an AWD car. Best bet is to NEVER put a donut on a drive wheel. If your drive wheel is flat, replace it with the tire from the rear of the same side, then put the spare on the rear corner.
#9
Originally Posted by soofle
Its not the speed that you drive that causes a problem with mounting a donut spare on the drive wheels its the difference in circumference (distance around the outer edge of the tire) Because the donut is so much smaller it causes a significant difference in the rotational speed of the wheels on each side. If this is happening on a drive wheel, this causes the differential (LSD or otherwise) to constantly compensate just as if you were driving in a continuous circle instead of in a straight line. Given time that can lead to premature wearing of the differential components and failure. The same is true for putting a donut on the back of a rear wheel drive or ANY corner of an AWD car. Best bet is to NEVER put a donut on a drive wheel. If your drive wheel is flat, replace it with the tire from the rear of the same side, then put the spare on the rear corner.
#10
#12
Originally Posted by YuccaPatrol
To add to Pete's post, the compact spare should not be installed in the front under any circumstances on a front wheel drive car. . .
#13
I've got a Cooper and haven't checked the manual, but the last time there was a flat on an S, I loaned them my spare--we just swapped the rear tire to the front, then put the donut in the rear. Makes sense from a handling issue to keep the front (powered) wheels equal.
Originally Posted by utahrpm
Thanks guys, good advice. So if the compact spare should not be installed on the front (drive) wheels, what does the Cooper's manual say about that?
#14
Originally Posted by OctaneGuy
I've got a Cooper and haven't checked the manual, but the last time there was a flat on an S, I loaned them my spare--we just swapped the rear tire to the front, then put the donut in the rear. Makes sense from a handling issue to keep the front (powered) wheels equal.
#15
yep, that is a BS
Originally Posted by utahrpm
I agree it makes sense from a handling point. I just wonder what "Mr. void your warranty" has to say about it. I don't believe my Boxster manual prohibits installing the compact spare on the drive wheels. I really want to call Bulls--t on the dealer or Mini parts rep.. thanks
#16
For short distances, a compact spare on the front is generally not an issue. Where it becomes an issue is cars equipped with LSDs. The constant rotational speed difference caused by dissimilar diameter wheels on the 'driving axle' of the car is rough on the LSD. Best to only drive as much as needed to repair the tire, if not, swap the spare onto the rear (of a MINI) if you have some distance to cover.
#17
Originally Posted by utahrpm
the invoice needed to state that in the case of any suspension, ABS, DSC, etc. problems, the warranty was void!! .
Originally Posted by YuccaPatrol
They are the ones that tried to tell me that driving through the mountains on a single weekend trip had voided my warranty on unmodified unaltered stock OEM brakes!
#18
Compact spare
A good source for a donut tire to fit the wheel is through a Ford dealer.
They use a 125-70R-15 on most medium and full size Fords. A lot of times
they have new or almost new tires laying around. This is what I did and
the tire (new) cost me only $30.00 mounted to a Ford wheel; I then sold
the Ford wheel for $10.00 - net cost to me for a new tire $20.00
They use a 125-70R-15 on most medium and full size Fords. A lot of times
they have new or almost new tires laying around. This is what I did and
the tire (new) cost me only $30.00 mounted to a Ford wheel; I then sold
the Ford wheel for $10.00 - net cost to me for a new tire $20.00
#23
#24
Originally Posted by alecmcpherson
where would you store a compact spare in my mini S?
#25
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Alexandria, VA - Old Town
Posts: 935
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by Yucca Patrol
To add to Pete's post, the compact spare should not be installed in the front under any circumstances on a front wheel drive car. . .
word! never install a spare tire on the drive end of any car. unless you want to start looking into a new differential in about 2k miles.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ECSTuning
Vendor Classifieds
0
10-01-2015 12:34 PM
ECSTuning
Interior/Exterior Products
0
10-01-2015 12:28 PM
ECSTuning
Vendor Classifieds
0
10-01-2015 12:28 PM
ECSTuning
Vendor Announcements
0
10-01-2015 12:13 PM